Seventh
of the readings, one book at its own scale — the first
frame the blog has been asked to read that fits in a hand, two
researchers each arguing from their own book, and a centuries-old
dispute that can be audited from a library by anyone with no stake in
the answer
Seventh of the readings, and the first whose unit is
not an argument but an object. The frames series — the frame is a variable through the cosmos that refuses — is about
cosmologies: what a culture takes reality to be, whether a frame names
an endpoint, whether it leaves a seat. This book is
about two decks of cards, and a deck is a frame of a different shape — a
fixed table of correspondences, a set of positions, and a reader who
supplies the reading. It is a frame you carry in a pocket, lay out on a
table and read aloud: the first frame in the series that fits in
a hand.
Status. This post reads one source. The
quotations are verbatim from a complete digital text of the edition,
checked character for character against it, and cited in the notes
by part and by speaker — because this
book is a recorded conversation, not a monograph: every
claim in it belongs to the person who made it, not to “the book”.
Typographic quotes are rendered here as straight ASCII, and dashes are
given as em dashes except inside numeric ranges (which keep its en
dashes); the spaces its italics markup leaves around punctuation are
closed; a quotation’s opening capital is normalised to its position in
the sentence; and the source’s footnote numbers are dropped from
quotations. The reading of the quotations is an
inference, offered as one. The book’s cosmology
is not endorsed — nothing here claims the cards carry real
magical power, and nothing claims they do not. No living author or
scholar is diagnosed, the Dummett-Yates dispute is described as a
structure and not adjudicated, and nothing here
validates, disqualifies or restricts anyone’s practice.*
1.
What the book is, and why it needs a reading rather than a
quotation
Two Esoteric Tarots is by Peter Mark Adams and Christophe
Poncet, “Convened & with a foreword by César Pedreros”, published by
Scarlet Imprint in 2023.Peter Mark Adams and Christophe Poncet, Two Esoteric
Tarots, convened and with a foreword by César Pedreros, Scarlet
Imprint, 2023; eISBN 978-1-912316-92-2. Read from a complete digital
text of that edition, which is what every quotation was checked against.
Front matter (line breaks shown as ” / “):”Peter Mark Adams &
Christophe Poncet / Convened & with a foreword by César Pedreros /
SCARLET IMPRINT MMXXIII”; “© Peter Mark Adams & Christophe Poncet
2023”; “Edited by Peter Grey / copy edits by Paul Holman / design &
typography by Alkistis Dimech”. The image credits are a separate
“Illustrations” list citing the Pinacoteca di Brera, Milano for the
Sola-Busca, the Bibliothèque nationale de France for the Noblet
Tarot de Marseille, the Musée Français de la Carte à Jouer for
the Chariot of Issy, and the Szépművészeti Múzeum for a Ficino medal.
The text carries no page numbers; its twelve parts are
headed “PART I” to “PART XII”, the contents listing naming them “Two
journeys into the tarot”, “Occult, esoteric and performative”, “Decoding
the Sola-Busca”, “How the tarot became esoteric”, “Of libertine
aesthetics: the grotesque and the abject”, “The Hellenistic revolution
and the second renaissance”, “Tarot designers”, “The Dummett-Yates
controversy”, “Cyphers and time”, “The seven planets”, “Orality, writing
and the art of memory” and “The esoteric call”, then “Bibliography” and
“Index”. Both authors’ own books are named in the text and notes: Adams,
P. M. (2017) The Game of Saturn: Decoding the Sola-Busca
Tarocchi, London: Scarlet Imprint, listed in the bibliography
alongside Mystai (2019) and Hagia Sophia / Sanctum of
Kronos (2023); Poncet’s The Tarot of Marsilio, footnoted
as “to be published by Scarlet Imprint in 2024”; and Poncet’s articles,
including “Ficino’s Little Academy of Careggi”, Bruniana &
Campanelliana XIX, 67–76, and “Le triomphe de la vie”, Bruniana
& Campanelliana XXIII, 505–512. Its front matter says what it is in
the convenor’s own sentence:
“A conversation was convened for the Sagittarius Full Moon of 3rd
June 2023. This is the record of that meeting of minds.”Two Esoteric Tarots, Foreword, by César
Pedreros (June 2023, Santiago de Chile). “SCHOLARLY RESEARCH
HAS FIRMLY MAINTAINED THAT THE tarot had no spiritual, esoteric or
divinatory dimension before the mid-eighteenth century. However, two
independent experts have shattered that consensus with their original
research.” (the text sets the opening in small capitals; the phrase “the
tarot had” is lower case in a run of capitals). “Peter Mark Adams has
traced the origins and meaning of the fifteenth-century Ferrarese
Sola-Busca tarocchi. … The evidence he presents unequivocally challenges
the notion that the tarot served as a mere game of chance; instead, it
is an artefact imbued with a magical purpose. It is evident that this
tarot, dating back to c.1490, predates the commonly accepted time frame
of esoteric use by almost three centuries.”. “Simultaneously, akin to a
Jungian synchronicity, the researcher Christophe Poncet had discerned
unmistakable traces of Platonic philosophy within the imagery of the
Tarot de Marseille. This revelation propelled him into a profound
historical investigation, unearthing connections between the Florentine
aristocracy, the Medici family, Marsilio Ficino, Botticelli, and the
heretical philosophical underpinnings of the Italian Renaissance.”. “A
conversation was convened for the Sagittarius Full Moon of 3rd June
2023. This is the record of that meeting of minds.”. “Tell me and I’ll
forget, show me and I may remember, involve me and I’ll understand.”
(the text’s italics markup leaves a space before each comma, closed
here).
That sentence governs this reading. The book is twelve parts long and
every part opens with a question from Pedreros — a
diffident, well-read interviewer in Santiago de Chile, who ends his
foreword with a proverb: “Tell me and I’ll forget, show me and I may
remember, involve me and I’ll understand.”Two Esoteric Tarots, Foreword, by César
Pedreros (June 2023, Santiago de Chile). “SCHOLARLY RESEARCH
HAS FIRMLY MAINTAINED THAT THE tarot had no spiritual, esoteric or
divinatory dimension before the mid-eighteenth century. However, two
independent experts have shattered that consensus with their original
research.” (the text sets the opening in small capitals; the phrase “the
tarot had” is lower case in a run of capitals). “Peter Mark Adams has
traced the origins and meaning of the fifteenth-century Ferrarese
Sola-Busca tarocchi. … The evidence he presents unequivocally challenges
the notion that the tarot served as a mere game of chance; instead, it
is an artefact imbued with a magical purpose. It is evident that this
tarot, dating back to c.1490, predates the commonly accepted time frame
of esoteric use by almost three centuries.”. “Simultaneously, akin to a
Jungian synchronicity, the researcher Christophe Poncet had discerned
unmistakable traces of Platonic philosophy within the imagery of the
Tarot de Marseille. This revelation propelled him into a profound
historical investigation, unearthing connections between the Florentine
aristocracy, the Medici family, Marsilio Ficino, Botticelli, and the
heretical philosophical underpinnings of the Italian Renaissance.”. “A
conversation was convened for the Sagittarius Full Moon of 3rd June
2023. This is the record of that meeting of minds.”. “Tell me and I’ll
forget, show me and I may remember, involve me and I’ll understand.”
(the text’s italics markup leaves a space before each comma, closed
here).
Adams is the author of The Game of Saturn: Decoding the Sola-Busca
Tarocchi (2017); Poncet of a forthcoming The Tarot of
Marsilio.Peter Mark Adams and Christophe Poncet, Two Esoteric
Tarots, convened and with a foreword by César Pedreros, Scarlet
Imprint, 2023; eISBN 978-1-912316-92-2. Read from a complete digital
text of that edition, which is what every quotation was checked against.
Front matter (line breaks shown as ” / “):”Peter Mark Adams &
Christophe Poncet / Convened & with a foreword by César Pedreros /
SCARLET IMPRINT MMXXIII”; “© Peter Mark Adams & Christophe Poncet
2023”; “Edited by Peter Grey / copy edits by Paul Holman / design &
typography by Alkistis Dimech”. The image credits are a separate
“Illustrations” list citing the Pinacoteca di Brera, Milano for the
Sola-Busca, the Bibliothèque nationale de France for the Noblet
Tarot de Marseille, the Musée Français de la Carte à Jouer for
the Chariot of Issy, and the Szépművészeti Múzeum for a Ficino medal.
The text carries no page numbers; its twelve parts are
headed “PART I” to “PART XII”, the contents listing naming them “Two
journeys into the tarot”, “Occult, esoteric and performative”, “Decoding
the Sola-Busca”, “How the tarot became esoteric”, “Of libertine
aesthetics: the grotesque and the abject”, “The Hellenistic revolution
and the second renaissance”, “Tarot designers”, “The Dummett-Yates
controversy”, “Cyphers and time”, “The seven planets”, “Orality, writing
and the art of memory” and “The esoteric call”, then “Bibliography” and
“Index”. Both authors’ own books are named in the text and notes: Adams,
P. M. (2017) The Game of Saturn: Decoding the Sola-Busca
Tarocchi, London: Scarlet Imprint, listed in the bibliography
alongside Mystai (2019) and Hagia Sophia / Sanctum of
Kronos (2023); Poncet’s The Tarot of Marsilio, footnoted
as “to be published by Scarlet Imprint in 2024”; and Poncet’s articles,
including “Ficino’s Little Academy of Careggi”, Bruniana &
Campanelliana XIX, 67–76, and “Le triomphe de la vie”, Bruniana
& Campanelliana XXIII, 505–512. Both have brought a thesis; the
convenor has brought a question.On attribution, because the blog’s
proven failure mode is address. This is a recorded conversation among
three named participants, and the text labels turns by first name:
“César” is César Pedreros, the convenor;
“Peter” is Peter Mark Adams;
“Christophe” is Christophe Poncet. The Foreword is
signed “César Pedreros / June 2023, Santiago de Chile” (line break shown
as ” / “) and is attributed here to Pedreros alone — which matters,
because the sentences the book is known for are in it. Every quotation’s
speaker was established by finding the last turn label
before it, distinguishing a label from a mention: Poncet’s Part II
speech contains the phrases”Peter and I, and probably others” and “Peter
analysed the very elaborate and specific imagery of the Sola-Busca”,
neither of which is a turn, and a naive search for the names attributes
his words to Adams. Turn labels used here, in order of appearance: Part
I — César, Christophe, César, Christophe, César, Peter, César, Peter;
Part II — César, Peter, César, Peter, César, Christophe (through the end
of the part); Part III — César, Peter; Part IV — César, Christophe; Part
V — César, Peter; Part VI — César, Peter; Part VII — César, Peter,
César, Peter, César, Christophe, Peter; Part VIII — César, Peter,
Christophe; Part IX — César, Christophe, Peter, César, Peter, César,
Christophe, César, Peter, César, Christophe; Part X — César, Christophe,
César, Peter; Part XI — César, Christophe, César, Peter; Part XII —
César, Christophe, César, Christophe, Peter. A quotation whose speaker
is not established by this method is not attributed to a speaker in this
post.
The blog owes this one a reading because the blog has never
read the tarot, and the tarot is a frame. Every case study in
this series has been about an environment: something a person is inside,
which supplies the meaning of a state that cannot read itself. A deck of
cards is not an environment. It is a thing, and it is used — and because
it is a thing it can be exhibited, dated and checked, which is what §4
is about. Two absences belong at the top: the text carries no
page numbers, so every reference here is by part and by
speaker; and this reading never saw the cards.Peter Mark Adams and Christophe Poncet, Two Esoteric
Tarots, convened and with a foreword by César Pedreros, Scarlet
Imprint, 2023; eISBN 978-1-912316-92-2. Read from a complete digital
text of that edition, which is what every quotation was checked against.
Front matter (line breaks shown as ” / “):”Peter Mark Adams &
Christophe Poncet / Convened & with a foreword by César Pedreros /
SCARLET IMPRINT MMXXIII”; “© Peter Mark Adams & Christophe Poncet
2023”; “Edited by Peter Grey / copy edits by Paul Holman / design &
typography by Alkistis Dimech”. The image credits are a separate
“Illustrations” list citing the Pinacoteca di Brera, Milano for the
Sola-Busca, the Bibliothèque nationale de France for the Noblet
Tarot de Marseille, the Musée Français de la Carte à Jouer for
the Chariot of Issy, and the Szépművészeti Múzeum for a Ficino medal.
The text carries no page numbers; its twelve parts are
headed “PART I” to “PART XII”, the contents listing naming them “Two
journeys into the tarot”, “Occult, esoteric and performative”, “Decoding
the Sola-Busca”, “How the tarot became esoteric”, “Of libertine
aesthetics: the grotesque and the abject”, “The Hellenistic revolution
and the second renaissance”, “Tarot designers”, “The Dummett-Yates
controversy”, “Cyphers and time”, “The seven planets”, “Orality, writing
and the art of memory” and “The esoteric call”, then “Bibliography” and
“Index”. Both authors’ own books are named in the text and notes: Adams,
P. M. (2017) The Game of Saturn: Decoding the Sola-Busca
Tarocchi, London: Scarlet Imprint, listed in the bibliography
alongside Mystai (2019) and Hagia Sophia / Sanctum of
Kronos (2023); Poncet’s The Tarot of Marsilio, footnoted
as “to be published by Scarlet Imprint in 2024”; and Poncet’s articles,
including “Ficino’s Little Academy of Careggi”, Bruniana &
Campanelliana XIX, 67–76, and “Le triomphe de la vie”, Bruniana
& Campanelliana XXIII, 505–512.
2.
The frame in a hand — the correspondence, the positions, the reader
Here is the post’s central reading, and it is an inference from the
book’s descriptions.
The owned cosmos distilled the
series into three questions: does the frame name the endpoint? Is it
checkable by someone who does not benefit? And does it leave a
seat? A tarot deck answers all three — by being built out of three
parts that are not a cosmology at all.
One: a correspondence system — a fixed, finite table
in which each card is an attribute. Poncet states one with unusual
precision, working from a passage in Ficino’s commentary on Plato’s
Timaeus in which the soul is “compared to a triple septenary,
so a three times seven structure”:
“A three times seven grid has twenty-one cells, so one for each
arcanum of the tarot, given that two of the trumps form a single
arcanum: the one that has no name (Arcanum XIII) and the one
that has no number (The Fool), forming together the inferior
arcanum of Saturn. In this way, the grid could be seen as the hidden
structure of the Tarot de Marseille, within which all the trumps could
be ordered.”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part X (“The seven
planets”). Christophe Poncet: “In Ficino’s commentary
on Plato’s Timaeus, there is a passage, about one page long, in
which the soul is compared to a triple septenary, so a three times seven
structure. … The seven planets all appear in it, and we understand that
the structure of the soul has three levels — the superior, the inferior
and the intermediary — and seven columns, one for each planet of the
Ptolemaic system … The sentences in which the planets are mentioned make
no sense in themselves. However, when I tried to compare these sentences
with the trumps of the Tarot de Marseille, I realised they were puns or
wordplays or clues hinting at the arcana. A three times seven grid has
twenty-one cells, so one for each arcanum of the tarot, given that two
of the trumps form a single arcanum: the one that has no name
(Arcanum XIII) and the one that has no number (The
Fool), forming together the inferior arcanum of Saturn. In this
way, the grid could be seen as the hidden structure of the Tarot de
Marseille, within which all the trumps could be ordered.”. “To give a
precise answer to the question, I don’t think the planetary divinities
mentioned in most of Ficino’s astrological writings, and thus the grid I
just described for the Tarot de Marseille, should be understood as
referring to celestial bodies acting on things and people. For him, the
planets have no influence on the sublunar world. They are signs that
reveal the universe … In the Tarot de Marseille, astrological allusions
should most probably be seen as analogies put at the service of the
description of souls.”. Peter Adams replies: “Yes, it’s
a much more minimalistic situation with the Sola-Busca because the only
celestial … and sidereal bodies … that can be discerned, are all
malefic.”
That is a table: three levels of being by seven
planets, twenty-one cells, one card each — and a closed one, since “If
we think of the game as a combinatorial system, you need every part to
make it work. So, it’s a complete system and each part has its
function.”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part IX (“Cyphers and
time”). Christophe Poncet: “If we think of the game as
a combinatorial system, you need every part to make it work. So, it’s a
complete system and each part has its function.”. “My research shows
that the Tarot de Marseille was designed between 1470 and 1475. The
Sola-Busca was probably created about ten years later in reaction to
Ficino’s deck, proposing in similar ways an opposite ideology.”; and, on
Ficino’s doctrine of the incarnate soul: “For him, the journey of the
soul during physical life necessarily leads to a state of madness. The
soul becomes crazed when it is incarnated because, being immortal, her
natural state is not to be imprisoned in a body, it is to be united with
God.”. Peter Adams: “What I perceive with respect to
the Sola-Busca is that each of the trumps, and certain of the suit
cards, form an elaborate cypher composed of some combination of
historical or literary references, astro-alchemical allusions and ritual
postures, gestures and magical implements. That being said, the recovery
of the ‘sense’ — the cards’ deeper narratives — requires that these
figures be grouped together in specific combinations.”. On time: “These
operations depend upon drawing in very specific forces — the energies of
Mars, Saturn and chthonic Mercury under the influence of the most
malefic of fixed stars, Algol — at the time of their maximum strength.
There’s a high degree of precision in the calculations required to
achieve this. You would need to be an astrologer to make all of the
calculations … All of the other operations would require equally precise
timing — the collection of the menstruum, the preparation of the ritual
space, garments, implements and the person of the Mage. With the
Sola-Busca, therefore, we encounter time in its most instrumental
sense”. “The whole operation functions like a very complicated,
intricate timepiece … In other words, we find ourselves at a very
instrumental end of the spiritual spectrum, one more usually associated
with goetia than with classical theurgy. This is a technocratic,
astrologically-driven vision of the universe as a collection of
manipulable forces. Ritually, the deck does not pose a question, it
instructs us on how to draw this power down in its rawest form and
manifest it into the external world. It is highly disciplined — which
is, of course, a highly Saturnian quality.”. A complete system in which each part
has a function is a vocabulary. The cosmos that refuses described
“The frame with a correspondence and no endpoint”; this one has both,
and the endpoint is small.
Two: a set of positions, described from the far side
while Adams decodes an unrelated deck: “Considered in isolation, the
cards are inherently polysemous. We therefore need to assemble a group
of cards in order to understand how they function together”,Two Esoteric Tarots, Part III (“Decoding the
Sola-Busca”), Peter Adams, throughout: “At the deepest
level I found that the Sola-Busca’s iconographic programme was
structured around two key rituals. The first was an extremely archaic
ritual, one attested as early as 700 BCE and still practiced by occult
groups today. It is called ‘Drawing Down the Moon.’”. “In effect what
the ritual is doing is creating a magical child or homunculus that will
then be ‘sacrificed’ by immolation in the next stage of the ritual as
part of an invocation of the saturnian deity or current (whether
encompassed under the name of Ammon, Kronos or Saturn).”. “The designer
has sought to hide the ritual intent through the use of additional
references that draw our attention away from the performative ritual
narrative being enacted.”. “The second ritual encompasses the main
objective of the entire ritual sequence. It is a rite of theurgical
invocation whereby the operator seeks to become imbued with the
draconian energies of the deity.”. “He is shown using a globular ritual
implement that we find described in the principal text of theurgical
practice, the Chaldean Oracles, and known as Hekate’s Top.”;
“As far as I know, this is the only depiction of a theurgical operation
in the entire oeuvre of both esoteric and Renaissance art.”. “My
suggestion is that only one reading — that identifying a deeply
heretical theurgical ritual — reflects the intent of the designer since
this alone is consistent with the deck’s other ritually-infused
imagery.”. “Considered in isolation, the cards are inherently
polysemous. We therefore need to assemble a group of cards in order to
understand how they function together and this allows us to begin to
recover the deck’s deeper levels of meaning.”. On method, from the same
part and cited in the body as the four named steps: the deck’s
“celestial and sidereal symbolism — references to the solstices,
planets, fixed stars and constellations”; the “surplus imagery left over
after accounting for the other elements”, which yielded “a distinctive
postural and gestural grammar — what I have called a ‘ritual grammar’”;
and the gesture “known as aposkopein; a characteristic gesture
made in the presence of an epiphany of a deity. We find this gesture
attested from at least the second millennium BCE in the context of
Minoan and Mycenaean iconography.”. and again, “The recovery of the
‘sense’ — the cards’ deeper narratives — requires that these figures be
grouped together in specific combinations.”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part IX (“Cyphers and
time”). Christophe Poncet: “If we think of the game as
a combinatorial system, you need every part to make it work. So, it’s a
complete system and each part has its function.”. “My research shows
that the Tarot de Marseille was designed between 1470 and 1475. The
Sola-Busca was probably created about ten years later in reaction to
Ficino’s deck, proposing in similar ways an opposite ideology.”; and, on
Ficino’s doctrine of the incarnate soul: “For him, the journey of the
soul during physical life necessarily leads to a state of madness. The
soul becomes crazed when it is incarnated because, being immortal, her
natural state is not to be imprisoned in a body, it is to be united with
God.”. Peter Adams: “What I perceive with respect to
the Sola-Busca is that each of the trumps, and certain of the suit
cards, form an elaborate cypher composed of some combination of
historical or literary references, astro-alchemical allusions and ritual
postures, gestures and magical implements. That being said, the recovery
of the ‘sense’ — the cards’ deeper narratives — requires that these
figures be grouped together in specific combinations.”. On time: “These
operations depend upon drawing in very specific forces — the energies of
Mars, Saturn and chthonic Mercury under the influence of the most
malefic of fixed stars, Algol — at the time of their maximum strength.
There’s a high degree of precision in the calculations required to
achieve this. You would need to be an astrologer to make all of the
calculations … All of the other operations would require equally precise
timing — the collection of the menstruum, the preparation of the ritual
space, garments, implements and the person of the Mage. With the
Sola-Busca, therefore, we encounter time in its most instrumental
sense”. “The whole operation functions like a very complicated,
intricate timepiece … In other words, we find ourselves at a very
instrumental end of the spiritual spectrum, one more usually associated
with goetia than with classical theurgy. This is a technocratic,
astrologically-driven vision of the universe as a collection of
manipulable forces. Ritually, the deck does not pose a question, it
instructs us on how to draw this power down in its rawest form and
manifest it into the external world. It is highly disciplined — which
is, of course, a highly Saturnian quality.”.
That is the spread, stated as a requirement: the positions are
not in the deck. The deck supplies a vocabulary, the
deal supplies the grammar, and the grammar is the part nobody owns.
Three: a reader — and the book’s most exact account
of that reader is Adams’s definition of the esoteric, which he grounds
not in doctrine but in an occasion: “The ‘esoteric tarot’ rests fully
upon a performative occasion; one in which there is a distinct
experience of some degree of automatism — whether conceived as entering
a state of flow, intuition or external facilitation.” And then this:
“Therein, for a space of time, the reader and the reading appear to
occupy two different worlds, the reading appears to have taken on a
life, and a direction, of its own.”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part II, section “On the
Performative”, Peter Adams: “My own conclusion is that
the ‘esoteric tarot’ rests fully upon a performative occasion; one in
which there is a distinct experience of some degree of automatism —
whether conceived as entering a state of flow, intuition or external
facilitation. Therein, for a space of time, the reader and the reading
appear to occupy two different worlds, the reading appears to have taken
on a life, and a direction, of its own.”. “Such is the archetypal nature
of its imagery, the tarot has the capacity to act as a container for a
broad range of spiritual impulses.”. “Twenty-five years ago, I met a
tarot teacher who enlightened me as to the existence of an initiatory
tradition in relation to the tarot (whether bestowed ‘in spirit’ or
through a lineage holder) and accompanied by ‘signs following’ that
serve to confirm the validity of the transmission. On occasion, tarot
rituals may be empowered by such a tradition. This is seldom spoken of,
or even alluded to, within the vast corpus of tarot-related
literature.”. César Pedreros opened the part: “Since
we’re framing our conversation with the term ‘esoteric tarot’ it is
important to address what we understand by esoteric”.
So the deck has a table, a set of positions, and a person who speaks.
Does it name the endpoint? Yes — but the endpoint is an
utterance. A cosmology names where you are going; a
deck names what is the case, now, about a question the querent brought.
It is a smaller claim than any frame in the series, and a stranger one:
it is made in the first person by someone in the room.
Is it checkable by someone who does not benefit?
Here the object does what no cosmology could: it splits the
question in two. The table is public, fixed and inert — anyone
can check whether a card sits where a table says it sits, and the check
changes nothing. The utterance is not checkable, and is issued by
someone who benefits from its holding. The
owned cosmos required a single check; the deck hands the blog a
checkable component and an uncheckable one welded into one object. Which
of the two has been argued over is §4’s answer: the table.
Does it leave a seat? Yes, and this is the reading’s
sharpest point — because here the seat is visible. The owned cosmos’s
seat is inside the frame and has to be inferred; a deck puts its
mediator in the chair opposite you with the cards in their hands. The
series’ finding was that “the frame is not the harm. The closed seat
is.” A reading is a seat open by default — and it
closes at one moment, which Adams’s sentence names exactly: when the
reader reports that “the reading appears to have taken on a life, and a
direction, of its own.” That is the structural shape of the machine said so: an authority that
cannot be argued with, because there is nobody to argue with — except
that here there is somebody present, and the automatism claim
is what removes them from the line of responsibility. The move which
closes this seat is a claim about who is speaking.
And the book supplies the blog with the adjective.
Adams describes time in the Sola-Busca’s ritual programme and reaches
for the word twice: “we encounter time in its most instrumental
sense”;Two Esoteric Tarots, Part IX (“Cyphers and
time”). Christophe Poncet: “If we think of the game as
a combinatorial system, you need every part to make it work. So, it’s a
complete system and each part has its function.”. “My research shows
that the Tarot de Marseille was designed between 1470 and 1475. The
Sola-Busca was probably created about ten years later in reaction to
Ficino’s deck, proposing in similar ways an opposite ideology.”; and, on
Ficino’s doctrine of the incarnate soul: “For him, the journey of the
soul during physical life necessarily leads to a state of madness. The
soul becomes crazed when it is incarnated because, being immortal, her
natural state is not to be imprisoned in a body, it is to be united with
God.”. Peter Adams: “What I perceive with respect to
the Sola-Busca is that each of the trumps, and certain of the suit
cards, form an elaborate cypher composed of some combination of
historical or literary references, astro-alchemical allusions and ritual
postures, gestures and magical implements. That being said, the recovery
of the ‘sense’ — the cards’ deeper narratives — requires that these
figures be grouped together in specific combinations.”. On time: “These
operations depend upon drawing in very specific forces — the energies of
Mars, Saturn and chthonic Mercury under the influence of the most
malefic of fixed stars, Algol — at the time of their maximum strength.
There’s a high degree of precision in the calculations required to
achieve this. You would need to be an astrologer to make all of the
calculations … All of the other operations would require equally precise
timing — the collection of the menstruum, the preparation of the ritual
space, garments, implements and the person of the Mage. With the
Sola-Busca, therefore, we encounter time in its most instrumental
sense”. “The whole operation functions like a very complicated,
intricate timepiece … In other words, we find ourselves at a very
instrumental end of the spiritual spectrum, one more usually associated
with goetia than with classical theurgy. This is a technocratic,
astrologically-driven vision of the universe as a collection of
manipulable forces. Ritually, the deck does not pose a question, it
instructs us on how to draw this power down in its rawest form and
manifest it into the external world. It is highly disciplined — which
is, of course, a highly Saturnian quality.”. “we find ourselves at a very
instrumental end of the spiritual spectrum, one more usually associated
with goetia than with classical theurgy.”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part IX (“Cyphers and
time”). Christophe Poncet: “If we think of the game as
a combinatorial system, you need every part to make it work. So, it’s a
complete system and each part has its function.”. “My research shows
that the Tarot de Marseille was designed between 1470 and 1475. The
Sola-Busca was probably created about ten years later in reaction to
Ficino’s deck, proposing in similar ways an opposite ideology.”; and, on
Ficino’s doctrine of the incarnate soul: “For him, the journey of the
soul during physical life necessarily leads to a state of madness. The
soul becomes crazed when it is incarnated because, being immortal, her
natural state is not to be imprisoned in a body, it is to be united with
God.”. Peter Adams: “What I perceive with respect to
the Sola-Busca is that each of the trumps, and certain of the suit
cards, form an elaborate cypher composed of some combination of
historical or literary references, astro-alchemical allusions and ritual
postures, gestures and magical implements. That being said, the recovery
of the ‘sense’ — the cards’ deeper narratives — requires that these
figures be grouped together in specific combinations.”. On time: “These
operations depend upon drawing in very specific forces — the energies of
Mars, Saturn and chthonic Mercury under the influence of the most
malefic of fixed stars, Algol — at the time of their maximum strength.
There’s a high degree of precision in the calculations required to
achieve this. You would need to be an astrologer to make all of the
calculations … All of the other operations would require equally precise
timing — the collection of the menstruum, the preparation of the ritual
space, garments, implements and the person of the Mage. With the
Sola-Busca, therefore, we encounter time in its most instrumental
sense”. “The whole operation functions like a very complicated,
intricate timepiece … In other words, we find ourselves at a very
instrumental end of the spiritual spectrum, one more usually associated
with goetia than with classical theurgy. This is a technocratic,
astrologically-driven vision of the universe as a collection of
manipulable forces. Ritually, the deck does not pose a question, it
instructs us on how to draw this power down in its rawest form and
manifest it into the external world. It is highly disciplined — which
is, of course, a highly Saturnian quality.”.
Instrumental is the right word for the whole object. A
cosmology is a frame you are in; a deck is a frame you
operate. And Adams’s account of the art of memory gives
the mechanism by which an operable frame can also be durable, because a
transient experience must be encoded so it can be re-run:
“Because of the transience of these experiences, imagistic modes of
religiosity require that their core ritual processes, iconic imagery and
visionary outcomes — rather than a body of fixed doctrine — be encoded
in a form that allows the restitution of the ritual and verification of
its efficacy and visionary outcomes.”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part XI (“Orality,
writing & the art of memory”). César Pedreros asks:
“Throughout history, there has been a prevailing belief that esoteric
teachings should be safeguarded and transmitted orally, exclusively to
those prepared to receive them. This exclusivity was supposed to
maintain the integrity and sanctity of the knowledge.”.
Christophe Poncet: “The Tarot de Marseille, with its
multilayered content and combinatorial structure, is a fantastic
instrument to produce unique experiences in the reader, and in this way
excludes any form of literality.”. Peter Adams: “The
concept of the art, or theatre, of memory informs everything I’ve
written over the last twenty-five years. The reason is simple enough.
There are two distinct modes of religiosity: a ‘doctrinal mode’ and an
‘imagistic mode.’”; “Because of the transience of these experiences,
imagistic modes of religiosity require that their core ritual processes,
iconic imagery and visionary outcomes — rather than a body of fixed
doctrine — be encoded in a form that allows the restitution of the
ritual and verification of its efficacy and visionary outcomes. The
ideal form with which to capture these essential elements is that of the
Theatre of Memory.”. The “doctrinal”/“imagistic” distinction is there
credited to Whitehouse, H. (2002), “Modes of Religiosity”.
Read that as a specification and it is a specification for a
carrier: not a doctrine but a re-runnable apparatus —
and a deck of cards is its smallest working example.
3. The claims, and who makes
them
The book’s headline sentences are not the researchers’. They are in
the Foreword, and the Foreword is the convenor’s:
“Scholarly research has firmly maintained that the tarot had no
spiritual, esoteric or divinatory dimension before the mid-eighteenth
century. However, two independent experts have shattered that consensus
with their original research.”Two Esoteric Tarots, Foreword, by César
Pedreros (June 2023, Santiago de Chile). “SCHOLARLY RESEARCH
HAS FIRMLY MAINTAINED THAT THE tarot had no spiritual, esoteric or
divinatory dimension before the mid-eighteenth century. However, two
independent experts have shattered that consensus with their original
research.” (the text sets the opening in small capitals; the phrase “the
tarot had” is lower case in a run of capitals). “Peter Mark Adams has
traced the origins and meaning of the fifteenth-century Ferrarese
Sola-Busca tarocchi. … The evidence he presents unequivocally challenges
the notion that the tarot served as a mere game of chance; instead, it
is an artefact imbued with a magical purpose. It is evident that this
tarot, dating back to c.1490, predates the commonly accepted time frame
of esoteric use by almost three centuries.”. “Simultaneously, akin to a
Jungian synchronicity, the researcher Christophe Poncet had discerned
unmistakable traces of Platonic philosophy within the imagery of the
Tarot de Marseille. This revelation propelled him into a profound
historical investigation, unearthing connections between the Florentine
aristocracy, the Medici family, Marsilio Ficino, Botticelli, and the
heretical philosophical underpinnings of the Italian Renaissance.”. “A
conversation was convened for the Sagittarius Full Moon of 3rd June
2023. This is the record of that meeting of minds.”. “Tell me and I’ll
forget, show me and I may remember, involve me and I’ll understand.”
(the text’s italics markup leaves a space before each comma, closed
here).
(the text sets the opening in small capitals; the reading is the
same). Then three claims in order, with the second of them the sentence
this book is known for:
“The evidence he presents unequivocally challenges the notion that
the tarot served as a mere game of chance; instead, it is an artefact
imbued with a magical purpose. It is evident that this tarot, dating
back to c.1490, predates the commonly accepted time frame of esoteric
use by almost three centuries.”Two Esoteric Tarots, Foreword, by César
Pedreros (June 2023, Santiago de Chile). “SCHOLARLY RESEARCH
HAS FIRMLY MAINTAINED THAT THE tarot had no spiritual, esoteric or
divinatory dimension before the mid-eighteenth century. However, two
independent experts have shattered that consensus with their original
research.” (the text sets the opening in small capitals; the phrase “the
tarot had” is lower case in a run of capitals). “Peter Mark Adams has
traced the origins and meaning of the fifteenth-century Ferrarese
Sola-Busca tarocchi. … The evidence he presents unequivocally challenges
the notion that the tarot served as a mere game of chance; instead, it
is an artefact imbued with a magical purpose. It is evident that this
tarot, dating back to c.1490, predates the commonly accepted time frame
of esoteric use by almost three centuries.”. “Simultaneously, akin to a
Jungian synchronicity, the researcher Christophe Poncet had discerned
unmistakable traces of Platonic philosophy within the imagery of the
Tarot de Marseille. This revelation propelled him into a profound
historical investigation, unearthing connections between the Florentine
aristocracy, the Medici family, Marsilio Ficino, Botticelli, and the
heretical philosophical underpinnings of the Italian Renaissance.”. “A
conversation was convened for the Sagittarius Full Moon of 3rd June
2023. This is the record of that meeting of minds.”. “Tell me and I’ll
forget, show me and I may remember, involve me and I’ll understand.”
(the text’s italics markup leaves a space before each comma, closed
here).
and, “simultaneously, akin to a Jungian synchronicity”, Poncet “had
discerned unmistakable traces of Platonic philosophy within the imagery
of the Tarot de Marseille”, unearthing “connections between the
Florentine aristocracy, the Medici family, Marsilio Ficino, Botticelli,
and the heretical philosophical underpinnings of the Italian
Renaissance.”Two Esoteric Tarots, Foreword, by César
Pedreros (June 2023, Santiago de Chile). “SCHOLARLY RESEARCH
HAS FIRMLY MAINTAINED THAT THE tarot had no spiritual, esoteric or
divinatory dimension before the mid-eighteenth century. However, two
independent experts have shattered that consensus with their original
research.” (the text sets the opening in small capitals; the phrase “the
tarot had” is lower case in a run of capitals). “Peter Mark Adams has
traced the origins and meaning of the fifteenth-century Ferrarese
Sola-Busca tarocchi. … The evidence he presents unequivocally challenges
the notion that the tarot served as a mere game of chance; instead, it
is an artefact imbued with a magical purpose. It is evident that this
tarot, dating back to c.1490, predates the commonly accepted time frame
of esoteric use by almost three centuries.”. “Simultaneously, akin to a
Jungian synchronicity, the researcher Christophe Poncet had discerned
unmistakable traces of Platonic philosophy within the imagery of the
Tarot de Marseille. This revelation propelled him into a profound
historical investigation, unearthing connections between the Florentine
aristocracy, the Medici family, Marsilio Ficino, Botticelli, and the
heretical philosophical underpinnings of the Italian Renaissance.”. “A
conversation was convened for the Sagittarius Full Moon of 3rd June
2023. This is the record of that meeting of minds.”. “Tell me and I’ll
forget, show me and I may remember, involve me and I’ll understand.”
(the text’s italics markup leaves a space before each comma, closed
here).
Note the address, because it is the finding. “An
artefact imbued with a magical purpose” is César Pedreros, in a
foreword, summarising Adams’s book for a reader he is inviting in. It is
not a sentence Adams writes about his own research, and §6 reports what
the two researchers write instead. The strongest sentence in the book is
written by the person with the least to lose.
Adams’s claim is about the Sola-Busca tarocchi, an
engraved fifteenth-century Ferrarese deck, whose isolation he
establishes first: it “appears to have been preserved within titled
circles until its purchase by the Italian state in 2009 — a period of
some five hundred years”, and “only appeared in the public domain on
four occasions”.Two Esoteric Tarots, Part VII (“Tarot
designers”), Peter Adams except where marked. “The
Sola-Busca appears to have been preserved within titled circles until
its purchase by the Italian state in 2009 — a period of some five
hundred years. Prior to that, to the best of my knowledge, it only
appeared in the public domain on four occasions.”; “The first was when
some of the cards were described in Count Cicognara’s memoire on
intaglio printmaking in 1831; the second, when art historian and curator
Arthur M. Hind arranged an exhibition of black and white photographic
images of the cards in the British Museum in 1907, and then included
some images of the cards in his catalogue of early Italian engravings.”
and “The fourth exposure of the cards was via a limited edition
reproduction of the entire deck by Wolfgang Mayer in 1998, though I can
find no further information as to how or why he undertook this
project.”. “I personally find his attribution convincing based upon
stylistic comparisons with the artist’s other works”. “Now, assuming
that De Marchi is right about the engraver’s identity, and given the
generally accepted dates during which he was active as an artist
(1472–1501), then a date for the engraving work roughly concurrent with
the ostensible production date of 1491 is a reasonable conjecture.”;
“Since the colouration of the deck’s figures corresponds to the
theurgical energies to which the ritual processes depicted within it
relate, then we can assume that the theurgical knowledge encoded in the
cards was also current at the d’Este court in the same time frame.”. The
political account: “The 1482–84 Salt War with Venice had essentially
bankrupted the state and destroyed a large portion of her agricultural
economy.”; “the presence of the initials ‘MS’ and the encoding of the
date 1491 points towards the Venetian patrician, Marin Sanudo, as their
intended recipient”; “The date encoded on trump XIIII Bocho (fig.16),
1491, also marked the date at which Ferrara received the first tranche
of reparations from Venice. A coincidence?” and “The cards may well have
served as a ‘reward’ for Sanudo’s support since they are precisely the
kind of unique, expensive, visually engaging artefact that he, a
celebrated bibliophile, would subsequently have displayed in his
house.”. And, in Christophe Poncet’s turn: “Ficino
takes the precaution of introducing each and every work of Plato with a
commentary.” . The list prints a
first (Cicognara, 1831), a second
(Arthur M. Hind’s photographs at the British Museum, 1907) and a
fourth (Wolfgang Mayer’s reproduction, 1998) — and no
third. That is a whole-text observation, reported as one.Reported as a search result, and scoped to the text of
this edition. Case-insensitive counts over the book’s text.
Length: the Foreword is 1.8 per cent
of the text. Strong epistemic markers: “unequivocally”
occurs 1 time in the text, inside the Foreword;
“firmly” 3 times (in the Foreword, and twice
elsewhere); “shattered” 2 (in the Foreword, of the
scholarly consensus, and once more, of the medieval worldview);
“evident” 4 (one in the Foreword, three elsewhere).
Hedge markers, case-insensitive substring counts across the
whole text, the Foreword’s count in brackets: “probably” 20
(0), “seems” 10 (0), “likely” 8 (0), “may have” 7 (0), “apparently” 4
(0), “perhaps” 3 (0), “to my mind” 2 (0), “I guess” 1 (0), “I gather” 1
(0), “tentatively” 1 (0), “My suggestion” 1 (0), “conjecture” 1 (0),
“possible” 4 (0), “possibility” 1 (0) — 64 across the text, 0 in
the Foreword. Safeguard: “safeguard” returns
1 hit, inside “safeguarded”, in the convenor’s question
about transmitting knowledge. Pace: “pace” returns
6 hits and 0 as a word of its own;
every hit is inside “space” — “for a space of time”, “the ritual space”
twice, “twenty-two spaces”, “this turbulent political space” and “the
efficacious space of your own dreams”. Clinical and risk
vocabulary returning 0 hits: danger, warn, warning, doctor,
therap-, therapist, psychiatr-, psychiatric, psychiatry, psychotic,
clinical, hospital, crisis, suicid-, mental health, breakdown, seek
help, professional help, self-harm, mentor, dose, safety, ethic.
Near-misses: “risk” 1 (the historical
risk run by Renaissance practitioners); “precaution” 1
(Ficino’s commentary habit); “caution” 0 as a word of
its own and 1 as a substring of “precaution”; “madness”
2 (Ficino’s doctrine that the incarnate soul’s journey
“necessarily leads to a state of madness”, and an index entry);
“careful” 5 (all five about examining images or texts);
“psycho” 3, all inside “metempsychosis”; “supervis”
1 (Prisciani’s “design and supervision” of a fresco
cycle); “discipline” 2 (the Quadrivium, and “It is
highly disciplined”); “purif” 2 (of the soul);
“meditat” 8, of which 5 are the title of Tomberg’s
Meditations on the Tarot or references to it, 2 are “divination
and meditation”/“divination, meditative or ritual use”, and 1 is
“meditative ritual”. The word “third” occurs
1 time in the text (“thirdly” in Adams’s four decoding
steps) and does not appear in the third element of the deck’s four
public appearances. A search shows only what it indexes, so every count
here is scoped to the text of this edition.
Then the claim itself:
“At the deepest level I found that the Sola-Busca’s iconographic
programme was structured around two key rituals. The first was an
extremely archaic ritual, one attested as early as 700 BCE and still
practiced by occult groups today. It is called ‘Drawing Down the
Moon.’”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part III (“Decoding the
Sola-Busca”), Peter Adams, throughout: “At the deepest
level I found that the Sola-Busca’s iconographic programme was
structured around two key rituals. The first was an extremely archaic
ritual, one attested as early as 700 BCE and still practiced by occult
groups today. It is called ‘Drawing Down the Moon.’”. “In effect what
the ritual is doing is creating a magical child or homunculus that will
then be ‘sacrificed’ by immolation in the next stage of the ritual as
part of an invocation of the saturnian deity or current (whether
encompassed under the name of Ammon, Kronos or Saturn).”. “The designer
has sought to hide the ritual intent through the use of additional
references that draw our attention away from the performative ritual
narrative being enacted.”. “The second ritual encompasses the main
objective of the entire ritual sequence. It is a rite of theurgical
invocation whereby the operator seeks to become imbued with the
draconian energies of the deity.”. “He is shown using a globular ritual
implement that we find described in the principal text of theurgical
practice, the Chaldean Oracles, and known as Hekate’s Top.”;
“As far as I know, this is the only depiction of a theurgical operation
in the entire oeuvre of both esoteric and Renaissance art.”. “My
suggestion is that only one reading — that identifying a deeply
heretical theurgical ritual — reflects the intent of the designer since
this alone is consistent with the deck’s other ritually-infused
imagery.”. “Considered in isolation, the cards are inherently
polysemous. We therefore need to assemble a group of cards in order to
understand how they function together and this allows us to begin to
recover the deck’s deeper levels of meaning.”. On method, from the same
part and cited in the body as the four named steps: the deck’s
“celestial and sidereal symbolism — references to the solstices,
planets, fixed stars and constellations”; the “surplus imagery left over
after accounting for the other elements”, which yielded “a distinctive
postural and gestural grammar — what I have called a ‘ritual grammar’”;
and the gesture “known as aposkopein; a characteristic gesture
made in the presence of an epiphany of a deity. We find this gesture
attested from at least the second millennium BCE in the context of
Minoan and Mycenaean iconography.”.
the first of which, in his reading, “is creating a magical child or
homunculus that will then be ‘sacrificed’ by immolation in the next
stage of the ritual as part of an invocation of the saturnian deity or
current (whether encompassed under the name of Ammon, Kronos or
Saturn)”,Two Esoteric Tarots, Part III (“Decoding the
Sola-Busca”), Peter Adams, throughout: “At the deepest
level I found that the Sola-Busca’s iconographic programme was
structured around two key rituals. The first was an extremely archaic
ritual, one attested as early as 700 BCE and still practiced by occult
groups today. It is called ‘Drawing Down the Moon.’”. “In effect what
the ritual is doing is creating a magical child or homunculus that will
then be ‘sacrificed’ by immolation in the next stage of the ritual as
part of an invocation of the saturnian deity or current (whether
encompassed under the name of Ammon, Kronos or Saturn).”. “The designer
has sought to hide the ritual intent through the use of additional
references that draw our attention away from the performative ritual
narrative being enacted.”. “The second ritual encompasses the main
objective of the entire ritual sequence. It is a rite of theurgical
invocation whereby the operator seeks to become imbued with the
draconian energies of the deity.”. “He is shown using a globular ritual
implement that we find described in the principal text of theurgical
practice, the Chaldean Oracles, and known as Hekate’s Top.”;
“As far as I know, this is the only depiction of a theurgical operation
in the entire oeuvre of both esoteric and Renaissance art.”. “My
suggestion is that only one reading — that identifying a deeply
heretical theurgical ritual — reflects the intent of the designer since
this alone is consistent with the deck’s other ritually-infused
imagery.”. “Considered in isolation, the cards are inherently
polysemous. We therefore need to assemble a group of cards in order to
understand how they function together and this allows us to begin to
recover the deck’s deeper levels of meaning.”. On method, from the same
part and cited in the body as the four named steps: the deck’s
“celestial and sidereal symbolism — references to the solstices,
planets, fixed stars and constellations”; the “surplus imagery left over
after accounting for the other elements”, which yielded “a distinctive
postural and gestural grammar — what I have called a ‘ritual grammar’”;
and the gesture “known as aposkopein; a characteristic gesture
made in the presence of an epiphany of a deity. We find this gesture
attested from at least the second millennium BCE in the context of
Minoan and Mycenaean iconography.”. and the second of which is the
deck’s real purpose: “It is a rite of theurgical invocation whereby the
operator seeks to become imbued with the draconian energies of the
deity.”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part III (“Decoding the
Sola-Busca”), Peter Adams, throughout: “At the deepest
level I found that the Sola-Busca’s iconographic programme was
structured around two key rituals. The first was an extremely archaic
ritual, one attested as early as 700 BCE and still practiced by occult
groups today. It is called ‘Drawing Down the Moon.’”. “In effect what
the ritual is doing is creating a magical child or homunculus that will
then be ‘sacrificed’ by immolation in the next stage of the ritual as
part of an invocation of the saturnian deity or current (whether
encompassed under the name of Ammon, Kronos or Saturn).”. “The designer
has sought to hide the ritual intent through the use of additional
references that draw our attention away from the performative ritual
narrative being enacted.”. “The second ritual encompasses the main
objective of the entire ritual sequence. It is a rite of theurgical
invocation whereby the operator seeks to become imbued with the
draconian energies of the deity.”. “He is shown using a globular ritual
implement that we find described in the principal text of theurgical
practice, the Chaldean Oracles, and known as Hekate’s Top.”;
“As far as I know, this is the only depiction of a theurgical operation
in the entire oeuvre of both esoteric and Renaissance art.”. “My
suggestion is that only one reading — that identifying a deeply
heretical theurgical ritual — reflects the intent of the designer since
this alone is consistent with the deck’s other ritually-infused
imagery.”. “Considered in isolation, the cards are inherently
polysemous. We therefore need to assemble a group of cards in order to
understand how they function together and this allows us to begin to
recover the deck’s deeper levels of meaning.”. On method, from the same
part and cited in the body as the four named steps: the deck’s
“celestial and sidereal symbolism — references to the solstices,
planets, fixed stars and constellations”; the “surplus imagery left over
after accounting for the other elements”, which yielded “a distinctive
postural and gestural grammar — what I have called a ‘ritual grammar’”;
and the gesture “known as aposkopein; a characteristic gesture
made in the presence of an epiphany of a deity. We find this gesture
attested from at least the second millennium BCE in the context of
Minoan and Mycenaean iconography.”. The implement on the card he can
name — “known as Hekate’s Top”, “described in the principal text of
theurgical practice, the Chaldean Oracles” — and about it he
makes the strongest evidential claim in the book: “As far as I know,
this is the only depiction of a theurgical operation in the entire
oeuvre of both esoteric and Renaissance art.”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part III (“Decoding the
Sola-Busca”), Peter Adams, throughout: “At the deepest
level I found that the Sola-Busca’s iconographic programme was
structured around two key rituals. The first was an extremely archaic
ritual, one attested as early as 700 BCE and still practiced by occult
groups today. It is called ‘Drawing Down the Moon.’”. “In effect what
the ritual is doing is creating a magical child or homunculus that will
then be ‘sacrificed’ by immolation in the next stage of the ritual as
part of an invocation of the saturnian deity or current (whether
encompassed under the name of Ammon, Kronos or Saturn).”. “The designer
has sought to hide the ritual intent through the use of additional
references that draw our attention away from the performative ritual
narrative being enacted.”. “The second ritual encompasses the main
objective of the entire ritual sequence. It is a rite of theurgical
invocation whereby the operator seeks to become imbued with the
draconian energies of the deity.”. “He is shown using a globular ritual
implement that we find described in the principal text of theurgical
practice, the Chaldean Oracles, and known as Hekate’s Top.”;
“As far as I know, this is the only depiction of a theurgical operation
in the entire oeuvre of both esoteric and Renaissance art.”. “My
suggestion is that only one reading — that identifying a deeply
heretical theurgical ritual — reflects the intent of the designer since
this alone is consistent with the deck’s other ritually-infused
imagery.”. “Considered in isolation, the cards are inherently
polysemous. We therefore need to assemble a group of cards in order to
understand how they function together and this allows us to begin to
recover the deck’s deeper levels of meaning.”. On method, from the same
part and cited in the body as the four named steps: the deck’s
“celestial and sidereal symbolism — references to the solstices,
planets, fixed stars and constellations”; the “surplus imagery left over
after accounting for the other elements”, which yielded “a distinctive
postural and gestural grammar — what I have called a ‘ritual grammar’”;
and the gesture “known as aposkopein; a characteristic gesture
made in the presence of an epiphany of a deity. We find this gesture
attested from at least the second millennium BCE in the context of
Minoan and Mycenaean iconography.”.
The summary: “Uniquely, the Sola-Busca appears to have embodied the
actual ritual processes for performing theurgy.”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part VI (“The Hellenistic
revolution and the second renaissance”), Peter Adams,
throughout. “Uniquely, the Sola-Busca appears to have embodied the
actual ritual processes for performing theurgy.”. “Giovanni Aurispa
returned from Constantinople in 1423 and again in 1427, on each occasion
bringing hundreds of Hellenistic texts with him. Amongst these texts
were the complete works of Plato, Proclus, Plotinus, and most of
Iamblichus.”; “Their significance — especially the works of Proclus and
Iamblichus — was the performativity that was fundamental to their
approach as practicing polytheistic Hellenists.”; “So inspiring were
these ideas that they triggered a second Hellenistic Renaissance that
fundamentally influenced the subsequent course of European culture for
the next three centuries.”. “In addition, this alternative spiritual
path was under-written by two sources of authority: firstly, that
accorded to ancient texts which were conceived as emerging from a fount
of pristine wisdom (prisca theologia) at a time close to the
act of creation, and were thereby thought to be imbued with far greater
depth, wisdom and verisimilitude” (the italics run is closed up here).
“That said, the fact that these beliefs threatened to undermine the
institutional power of church and state meant that they could only be
preserved by being occluded within other media. From the proactive
perspective enjoined by theurgists, such as Proclus, the influence of
higher order energies, or deities, could be embodied via their
geometrical forms in artworks that would, henceforth, emanate their
distinctive presence into the world.”.
Two features of the claim’s form belong here. The
first is that the designer is said to have hidden it deliberately, and
the hiding is part of the argument: “The designer has sought to hide the
ritual intent through the use of additional references that draw our
attention away from the performative ritual narrative being enacted.”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part III (“Decoding the
Sola-Busca”), Peter Adams, throughout: “At the deepest
level I found that the Sola-Busca’s iconographic programme was
structured around two key rituals. The first was an extremely archaic
ritual, one attested as early as 700 BCE and still practiced by occult
groups today. It is called ‘Drawing Down the Moon.’”. “In effect what
the ritual is doing is creating a magical child or homunculus that will
then be ‘sacrificed’ by immolation in the next stage of the ritual as
part of an invocation of the saturnian deity or current (whether
encompassed under the name of Ammon, Kronos or Saturn).”. “The designer
has sought to hide the ritual intent through the use of additional
references that draw our attention away from the performative ritual
narrative being enacted.”. “The second ritual encompasses the main
objective of the entire ritual sequence. It is a rite of theurgical
invocation whereby the operator seeks to become imbued with the
draconian energies of the deity.”. “He is shown using a globular ritual
implement that we find described in the principal text of theurgical
practice, the Chaldean Oracles, and known as Hekate’s Top.”;
“As far as I know, this is the only depiction of a theurgical operation
in the entire oeuvre of both esoteric and Renaissance art.”. “My
suggestion is that only one reading — that identifying a deeply
heretical theurgical ritual — reflects the intent of the designer since
this alone is consistent with the deck’s other ritually-infused
imagery.”. “Considered in isolation, the cards are inherently
polysemous. We therefore need to assemble a group of cards in order to
understand how they function together and this allows us to begin to
recover the deck’s deeper levels of meaning.”. On method, from the same
part and cited in the body as the four named steps: the deck’s
“celestial and sidereal symbolism — references to the solstices,
planets, fixed stars and constellations”; the “surplus imagery left over
after accounting for the other elements”, which yielded “a distinctive
postural and gestural grammar — what I have called a ‘ritual grammar’”;
and the gesture “known as aposkopein; a characteristic gesture
made in the presence of an epiphany of a deity. We find this gesture
attested from at least the second millennium BCE in the context of
Minoan and Mycenaean iconography.”. A claim in which concealment is a
prediction can be strong evidence; it can also absorb counter-evidence.
The second is Adams’s own marking of its status — “My
suggestion is”, “a reasonable
conjecture” — with the date resting on an attribution
he does not make: “assuming that De Marchi is right about the engraver’s
identity”.Two Esoteric Tarots, Part VII (“Tarot
designers”), Peter Adams except where marked. “The
Sola-Busca appears to have been preserved within titled circles until
its purchase by the Italian state in 2009 — a period of some five
hundred years. Prior to that, to the best of my knowledge, it only
appeared in the public domain on four occasions.”; “The first was when
some of the cards were described in Count Cicognara’s memoire on
intaglio printmaking in 1831; the second, when art historian and curator
Arthur M. Hind arranged an exhibition of black and white photographic
images of the cards in the British Museum in 1907, and then included
some images of the cards in his catalogue of early Italian engravings.”
and “The fourth exposure of the cards was via a limited edition
reproduction of the entire deck by Wolfgang Mayer in 1998, though I can
find no further information as to how or why he undertook this
project.”. “I personally find his attribution convincing based upon
stylistic comparisons with the artist’s other works”. “Now, assuming
that De Marchi is right about the engraver’s identity, and given the
generally accepted dates during which he was active as an artist
(1472–1501), then a date for the engraving work roughly concurrent with
the ostensible production date of 1491 is a reasonable conjecture.”;
“Since the colouration of the deck’s figures corresponds to the
theurgical energies to which the ritual processes depicted within it
relate, then we can assume that the theurgical knowledge encoded in the
cards was also current at the d’Este court in the same time frame.”. The
political account: “The 1482–84 Salt War with Venice had essentially
bankrupted the state and destroyed a large portion of her agricultural
economy.”; “the presence of the initials ‘MS’ and the encoding of the
date 1491 points towards the Venetian patrician, Marin Sanudo, as their
intended recipient”; “The date encoded on trump XIIII Bocho (fig.16),
1491, also marked the date at which Ferrara received the first tranche
of reparations from Venice. A coincidence?” and “The cards may well have
served as a ‘reward’ for Sanudo’s support since they are precisely the
kind of unique, expensive, visually engaging artefact that he, a
celebrated bibliophile, would subsequently have displayed in his
house.”. And, in Christophe Poncet’s turn: “Ficino
takes the precaution of introducing each and every work of Plato with a
commentary.” .
Poncet’s claim is about the Tarot de Marseille, and
it begins in a bedroom: “On my nineteenth birthday, my girlfriend gifted
me a tarot deck. A Tarot de Marseille. I was amazed by the images of the
trump cards.”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part I (“Two journeys
into the tarot”), Christophe Poncet: “On my nineteenth
birthday, my girlfriend gifted me a tarot deck. A Tarot de Marseille. I
was amazed by the images of the trump cards. Before that I had used
ordinary playing cards to tell the future, as a fun practice.”. “The
earliest Tarot de Marseille cards we know of are a World trump and a few
pips found in the Castello Sforzesco in Milan, which could be dated to
the second half of the sixteenth century. … So the earliest material
samples postdate by almost a century the original deck’s creation.” .
“It is not by chance that all these cards represent the same kind of
figures, seated on thrones, with symbols of power such as crowns and
sceptres. They all are inspired by a single series of etchings by the
Florentine engraver Baccio Baldini, the Prophets and Sibyls,
dated circa 1471.” “Plato’s chariot of the soul, for instance, is
obviously reflected in the Chariot card of the Tarot de
Marseille, in a spectacular way”. “I discovered that the images of the
tarot are not so much Plato’s, but rather Ficino’s interpretation of
Plato’s images, and it’s noticeably different.”. On his criterion:
“Well, this is only the obvious reading of the card. I could not accept
it, because this interpretation does not account for all its details. In
particular, there is a plant-shaped structure running all along the back
of the skeleton, with a bulb rooted in the pelvis and a stem with leaves
climbing up the spine to the skull. This cannot be meaningless. … As for
any enigma, the solution needs to provide the key to all its given
elements.”. Peter Adams, later in the same part: “From
the beginning, I enjoyed an intense connection with the cards, engaging
with the tarot on many different levels: aesthetically, historically,
from a literary perspective and — last but not least — performatively;
chiefly in acts of divination and energy work.”; “I couldn’t believe
that anything that had had this much time and effort expended on it
wasn’t possessed of some deeper significance.”. His method is a dating argument by
costume, since playing cards are perishable and he has only the images:
the “Authorities” (Popess, Pope, Emperor, Empress, Justice) are
“inspired by a single series of etchings by the Florentine engraver
Baccio Baldini, the Prophets and Sibyls, dated circa 1471”,
putting the prototype in northern or central Italy around 1471.Two Esoteric Tarots, Part I (“Two journeys
into the tarot”), Christophe Poncet: “On my nineteenth
birthday, my girlfriend gifted me a tarot deck. A Tarot de Marseille. I
was amazed by the images of the trump cards. Before that I had used
ordinary playing cards to tell the future, as a fun practice.”. “The
earliest Tarot de Marseille cards we know of are a World trump and a few
pips found in the Castello Sforzesco in Milan, which could be dated to
the second half of the sixteenth century. … So the earliest material
samples postdate by almost a century the original deck’s creation.” .
“It is not by chance that all these cards represent the same kind of
figures, seated on thrones, with symbols of power such as crowns and
sceptres. They all are inspired by a single series of etchings by the
Florentine engraver Baccio Baldini, the Prophets and Sibyls,
dated circa 1471.” “Plato’s chariot of the soul, for instance, is
obviously reflected in the Chariot card of the Tarot de
Marseille, in a spectacular way”. “I discovered that the images of the
tarot are not so much Plato’s, but rather Ficino’s interpretation of
Plato’s images, and it’s noticeably different.”. On his criterion:
“Well, this is only the obvious reading of the card. I could not accept
it, because this interpretation does not account for all its details. In
particular, there is a plant-shaped structure running all along the back
of the skeleton, with a bulb rooted in the pelvis and a stem with leaves
climbing up the spine to the skull. This cannot be meaningless. … As for
any enigma, the solution needs to provide the key to all its given
elements.”. Peter Adams, later in the same part: “From
the beginning, I enjoyed an intense connection with the cards, engaging
with the tarot on many different levels: aesthetically, historically,
from a literary perspective and — last but not least — performatively;
chiefly in acts of divination and energy work.”; “I couldn’t believe
that anything that had had this much time and effort expended on it
wasn’t possessed of some deeper significance.”. Then Plato — “Plato’s chariot of
the soul, for instance, is obviously reflected in the Chariot
card of the Tarot de Marseille, in a spectacular way”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part I (“Two journeys
into the tarot”), Christophe Poncet: “On my nineteenth
birthday, my girlfriend gifted me a tarot deck. A Tarot de Marseille. I
was amazed by the images of the trump cards. Before that I had used
ordinary playing cards to tell the future, as a fun practice.”. “The
earliest Tarot de Marseille cards we know of are a World trump and a few
pips found in the Castello Sforzesco in Milan, which could be dated to
the second half of the sixteenth century. … So the earliest material
samples postdate by almost a century the original deck’s creation.” .
“It is not by chance that all these cards represent the same kind of
figures, seated on thrones, with symbols of power such as crowns and
sceptres. They all are inspired by a single series of etchings by the
Florentine engraver Baccio Baldini, the Prophets and Sibyls,
dated circa 1471.” “Plato’s chariot of the soul, for instance, is
obviously reflected in the Chariot card of the Tarot de
Marseille, in a spectacular way”. “I discovered that the images of the
tarot are not so much Plato’s, but rather Ficino’s interpretation of
Plato’s images, and it’s noticeably different.”. On his criterion:
“Well, this is only the obvious reading of the card. I could not accept
it, because this interpretation does not account for all its details. In
particular, there is a plant-shaped structure running all along the back
of the skeleton, with a bulb rooted in the pelvis and a stem with leaves
climbing up the spine to the skull. This cannot be meaningless. … As for
any enigma, the solution needs to provide the key to all its given
elements.”. Peter Adams, later in the same part: “From
the beginning, I enjoyed an intense connection with the cards, engaging
with the tarot on many different levels: aesthetically, historically,
from a literary perspective and — last but not least — performatively;
chiefly in acts of divination and energy work.”; “I couldn’t believe
that anything that had had this much time and effort expended on it
wasn’t possessed of some deeper significance.”. —
and then the intersection of the two, which produces the thesis:
“Someone, it may have been Ficino or a member of his Academy, figured
out that images can convey Ideas. The game of tarot was popular at that
time, so they imagined using its structure and figures to embed
philosophical images and concepts.”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part IV (“How the tarot
became esoteric”), Christophe Poncet: “At this point in
history, I guess there is no esoteric meaning to these images, they
probably just represent what they appear to represent.”. “In this
fertile intellectual context, someone, it may have been Ficino or a
member of his Academy, figured out that images can convey Ideas. The
game of tarot was popular at that time, so they imagined using its
structure and figures to embed philosophical images and concepts. It’s
not the work of a single man. There are many tasks; so, it probably
involved teamwork.” ; “they met in Ficino’s house in the hills that
dominate Florence, and there they discussed the texts of Plato, shared
ideas, drank wine, played the lyre and chanted Orphic hymns”;
“Conceiving and producing the game must have been an activity of the
Academy in itself.”. “Then they probably played the game, as a serious
game, and they might have invented new ways of using the deck. It may
already, at this point, have been used for divinatory purposes, and
there are several mentions of oracular practices in Ficino’s writings.”.
“However, until the death of Ficino, in 1499, I gather it was
exclusively reserved for a small circle of initiates.”.
with the refinement that keeps it from being stock Platonism — “I
discovered that the images of the tarot are not so much Plato’s, but
rather Ficino’s interpretation of Plato’s images, and it’s noticeably
different”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part I (“Two journeys
into the tarot”), Christophe Poncet: “On my nineteenth
birthday, my girlfriend gifted me a tarot deck. A Tarot de Marseille. I
was amazed by the images of the trump cards. Before that I had used
ordinary playing cards to tell the future, as a fun practice.”. “The
earliest Tarot de Marseille cards we know of are a World trump and a few
pips found in the Castello Sforzesco in Milan, which could be dated to
the second half of the sixteenth century. … So the earliest material
samples postdate by almost a century the original deck’s creation.” .
“It is not by chance that all these cards represent the same kind of
figures, seated on thrones, with symbols of power such as crowns and
sceptres. They all are inspired by a single series of etchings by the
Florentine engraver Baccio Baldini, the Prophets and Sibyls,
dated circa 1471.” “Plato’s chariot of the soul, for instance, is
obviously reflected in the Chariot card of the Tarot de
Marseille, in a spectacular way”. “I discovered that the images of the
tarot are not so much Plato’s, but rather Ficino’s interpretation of
Plato’s images, and it’s noticeably different.”. On his criterion:
“Well, this is only the obvious reading of the card. I could not accept
it, because this interpretation does not account for all its details. In
particular, there is a plant-shaped structure running all along the back
of the skeleton, with a bulb rooted in the pelvis and a stem with leaves
climbing up the spine to the skull. This cannot be meaningless. … As for
any enigma, the solution needs to provide the key to all its given
elements.”. Peter Adams, later in the same part: “From
the beginning, I enjoyed an intense connection with the cards, engaging
with the tarot on many different levels: aesthetically, historically,
from a literary perspective and — last but not least — performatively;
chiefly in acts of divination and energy work.”; “I couldn’t believe
that anything that had had this much time and effort expended on it
wasn’t possessed of some deeper significance.”. — and the date: “My research shows
that the Tarot de Marseille was designed between 1470 and 1475.”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part IX (“Cyphers and
time”). Christophe Poncet: “If we think of the game as
a combinatorial system, you need every part to make it work. So, it’s a
complete system and each part has its function.”. “My research shows
that the Tarot de Marseille was designed between 1470 and 1475. The
Sola-Busca was probably created about ten years later in reaction to
Ficino’s deck, proposing in similar ways an opposite ideology.”; and, on
Ficino’s doctrine of the incarnate soul: “For him, the journey of the
soul during physical life necessarily leads to a state of madness. The
soul becomes crazed when it is incarnated because, being immortal, her
natural state is not to be imprisoned in a body, it is to be united with
God.”. Peter Adams: “What I perceive with respect to
the Sola-Busca is that each of the trumps, and certain of the suit
cards, form an elaborate cypher composed of some combination of
historical or literary references, astro-alchemical allusions and ritual
postures, gestures and magical implements. That being said, the recovery
of the ‘sense’ — the cards’ deeper narratives — requires that these
figures be grouped together in specific combinations.”. On time: “These
operations depend upon drawing in very specific forces — the energies of
Mars, Saturn and chthonic Mercury under the influence of the most
malefic of fixed stars, Algol — at the time of their maximum strength.
There’s a high degree of precision in the calculations required to
achieve this. You would need to be an astrologer to make all of the
calculations … All of the other operations would require equally precise
timing — the collection of the menstruum, the preparation of the ritual
space, garments, implements and the person of the Mage. With the
Sola-Busca, therefore, we encounter time in its most instrumental
sense”. “The whole operation functions like a very complicated,
intricate timepiece … In other words, we find ourselves at a very
instrumental end of the spiritual spectrum, one more usually associated
with goetia than with classical theurgy. This is a technocratic,
astrologically-driven vision of the universe as a collection of
manipulable forces. Ritually, the deck does not pose a question, it
instructs us on how to draw this power down in its rawest form and
manifest it into the external world. It is highly disciplined — which
is, of course, a highly Saturnian quality.”. He then declines the definition the
book was convened to supply:
“I cannot give you a definition of the esoteric or occult tarot. What
I believe for certain, however, is that, very early in the history of
the tarot, some decks had uses other than gaming.”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part II (“Occult,
esoteric and performative”), Christophe Poncet’s answer
to the end of the part. “So, at the end of the twentieth century, when
three scholars, Ronald Decker, Thierry Depaulis and Michael Dummett
wrote a book on the origins of the occult tarot, they simply set the
starting point of their history at the end of the eighteenth century.
For them, the occult or esoteric tarot could only be an invention of the
French occultists. Before that, they asserted, ever since its origins,
the tarot had only been a game of cards, with no other meanings or
usages of any kind.”. “In this way, two different decks of the fifteenth
century revealed themselves as spectacular examples of esotericism in
tarot, more than three hundred years before the earliest date previously
accepted by academic consensus.”. “To conclude on that point, I cannot
give you a definition of the esoteric or occult tarot. What I believe
for certain, however, is that, very early in the history of the tarot,
some decks had uses other than gaming.”. This post has not read
Dummett, Depaulis or Yates, and its account of what they held
is taken from this book and marked as the book’s.
The shared claim, in Poncet’s words, is the sentence
the two researches are joined to:
“In this way, two different decks of the fifteenth century revealed
themselves as spectacular examples of esotericism in tarot, more than
three hundred years before the earliest date previously accepted by
academic consensus.”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part II (“Occult,
esoteric and performative”), Christophe Poncet’s answer
to the end of the part. “So, at the end of the twentieth century, when
three scholars, Ronald Decker, Thierry Depaulis and Michael Dummett
wrote a book on the origins of the occult tarot, they simply set the
starting point of their history at the end of the eighteenth century.
For them, the occult or esoteric tarot could only be an invention of the
French occultists. Before that, they asserted, ever since its origins,
the tarot had only been a game of cards, with no other meanings or
usages of any kind.”. “In this way, two different decks of the fifteenth
century revealed themselves as spectacular examples of esotericism in
tarot, more than three hundred years before the earliest date previously
accepted by academic consensus.”. “To conclude on that point, I cannot
give you a definition of the esoteric or occult tarot. What I believe
for certain, however, is that, very early in the history of the tarot,
some decks had uses other than gaming.”. This post has not read
Dummett, Depaulis or Yates, and its account of what they held
is taken from this book and marked as the book’s.
One small thing worth reporting rather than smoothing: the Foreword
says “almost three centuries” and Poncet says “more than three hundred
years”. The gap proves nothing, and it is the kind of arithmetic a
reading should not tidy on the author’s behalf.
4. The
check: a dispute that can be audited from a library
This is the part of the book the blog has direct use for, because the
blog’s test arrives here as an actual dispute between named people, in a
public record, with a stated standard of evidence.
Pedreros’s question frames it: “Or was Michael Dummett right when he
insisted that there was no such thing as an esoteric tarot before the
French occultists ‘discovered’ it in the eighteenth century?”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part VIII (“The
Dummett-Yates controversy”). César Pedreros asks: “Why
is it that we cannot find books explicitly explaining the esoteric
significance of these images until French occultism emerged in the
eighteenth century? Were they destroyed? Were they simply never written?
Or was Michael Dummett right when he insisted that there was no such
thing as an esoteric tarot before the French occultists ‘discovered’ it
in the eighteenth century?”. Peter Adams,:
“Unfortunately, for many people it’s as though the clock became stuck
back in 1980 when Dummett published his study of the tarot as a game,
and has remained so ever since, so that merely referring to Dummett has
become a standard response on this issue — as though nothing has changed
in the intervening almost half century.”. “To be clear, the central
issue rests on Dummett’s claim that ‘no occult significance was attached
to the cards, nor any use made of them save for playing games, until the
intervention of Court de Gébelin in 1781.’”. “This topic formed the
subject of an exchange between Michael Dummett, a professor of logic and
expert on tarot games, and Frances Yates, a world-renowned expert on the
iconography and ideation of the Renaissance, in the context of Yates’s
review of Dummett’s The Game of Tarot.”; “Rather than rehearse
the intricacies of this exchange the issue rested, finally, on Dummett’s
appeal for, and openness towards, evidence overturning his statement.” .
“The evidence that neither Dummett nor Yates had access to in 1980 has
only become available over the last ten years or so, and it
fundamentally overturns Dummett’s supposition. Frances Yates was right
but lacked the specifics to establish her case.”. “The first piece of
evidence comes from the records of the Inquisition. A Venetian
courtesan, Isabella Bellochio, was stated to have ‘worshipped an image
of the devil by kneeling before it, with her hair loose, while
maintaining a lantern alight before it day and night … a light which
burned continuously in the kitchen in front of a devil and the tarocchi
…’” (ellipses in the original, the footnote there giving Martin, R.
(1989) Witchcraft and the Inquisition in Venice, 1550–1650,
163). “Surely this kind of dual-use of a portable, highly symbolic
source of imagery is only to be expected?”; “In this connection it is
interesting that the Sola-Busca’s trump XVII Ipeo is the only card to
show signs of wear on the paint surface. It appears to have been
thumb-marked by being repeatedly gripped or held at the mid-opposite
edges, which is not, of course, evidence of ritual use but it certainly
points towards prolonged and sustained contemplation of the image.”.
“Today, the evidence for the existence of occluded subtexts deliberately
hidden within the pre-Gébelin tarot is threefold. It comprises the
detailed analyses of the iconography of the Sola-Busca (Adams); the
early Tarot de Marseille (Poncet); and the Noblet Tarot de Marseille
(Appel).”; “So the answer to the question about the ‘missing evidence’
is that it was never missing. Some of it existed in official records;
the rest, by far the more impactful portion, was hidden, rather
artfully, in plain sight for these last five hundred years.”.
Christophe Poncet,: “I completely agree with Peter. The
cards themselves were the ‘missing evidence.’”; “Such writings do not
state ‘I have created a tarot deck that embodies my ideas and theurgical
practices,’ as the followers of Dummett seem to expect, because their
authors couldn’t express themselves openly.”; “He was a very intelligent
man. He was a professor of logic. And he knew a lot about philosophy,
but he seems not to have been familiar with the culture of the Italian
Renaissance. That probably explains his dry, austere and limited vision
of the tarot.”; “She wrote that Dummett should have spent more time
looking for the ideas embedded in the cards than to ‘chase obscure card
games’. To name the capacity of the cards to embed deep performative
knowledge, Yates chose the word ‘hieroglyph.’”. Adams answers by naming what the
disagreement is about, and quoting his opponent:
“The central issue rests on Dummett’s claim that ‘no occult
significance was attached to the cards, nor any use made of them save
for playing games, until the intervention of Court de Gébelin in
1781.’”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part VIII (“The
Dummett-Yates controversy”). César Pedreros asks: “Why
is it that we cannot find books explicitly explaining the esoteric
significance of these images until French occultism emerged in the
eighteenth century? Were they destroyed? Were they simply never written?
Or was Michael Dummett right when he insisted that there was no such
thing as an esoteric tarot before the French occultists ‘discovered’ it
in the eighteenth century?”. Peter Adams,:
“Unfortunately, for many people it’s as though the clock became stuck
back in 1980 when Dummett published his study of the tarot as a game,
and has remained so ever since, so that merely referring to Dummett has
become a standard response on this issue — as though nothing has changed
in the intervening almost half century.”. “To be clear, the central
issue rests on Dummett’s claim that ‘no occult significance was attached
to the cards, nor any use made of them save for playing games, until the
intervention of Court de Gébelin in 1781.’”. “This topic formed the
subject of an exchange between Michael Dummett, a professor of logic and
expert on tarot games, and Frances Yates, a world-renowned expert on the
iconography and ideation of the Renaissance, in the context of Yates’s
review of Dummett’s The Game of Tarot.”; “Rather than rehearse
the intricacies of this exchange the issue rested, finally, on Dummett’s
appeal for, and openness towards, evidence overturning his statement.” .
“The evidence that neither Dummett nor Yates had access to in 1980 has
only become available over the last ten years or so, and it
fundamentally overturns Dummett’s supposition. Frances Yates was right
but lacked the specifics to establish her case.”. “The first piece of
evidence comes from the records of the Inquisition. A Venetian
courtesan, Isabella Bellochio, was stated to have ‘worshipped an image
of the devil by kneeling before it, with her hair loose, while
maintaining a lantern alight before it day and night … a light which
burned continuously in the kitchen in front of a devil and the tarocchi
…’” (ellipses in the original, the footnote there giving Martin, R.
(1989) Witchcraft and the Inquisition in Venice, 1550–1650,
163). “Surely this kind of dual-use of a portable, highly symbolic
source of imagery is only to be expected?”; “In this connection it is
interesting that the Sola-Busca’s trump XVII Ipeo is the only card to
show signs of wear on the paint surface. It appears to have been
thumb-marked by being repeatedly gripped or held at the mid-opposite
edges, which is not, of course, evidence of ritual use but it certainly
points towards prolonged and sustained contemplation of the image.”.
“Today, the evidence for the existence of occluded subtexts deliberately
hidden within the pre-Gébelin tarot is threefold. It comprises the
detailed analyses of the iconography of the Sola-Busca (Adams); the
early Tarot de Marseille (Poncet); and the Noblet Tarot de Marseille
(Appel).”; “So the answer to the question about the ‘missing evidence’
is that it was never missing. Some of it existed in official records;
the rest, by far the more impactful portion, was hidden, rather
artfully, in plain sight for these last five hundred years.”.
Christophe Poncet,: “I completely agree with Peter. The
cards themselves were the ‘missing evidence.’”; “Such writings do not
state ‘I have created a tarot deck that embodies my ideas and theurgical
practices,’ as the followers of Dummett seem to expect, because their
authors couldn’t express themselves openly.”; “He was a very intelligent
man. He was a professor of logic. And he knew a lot about philosophy,
but he seems not to have been familiar with the culture of the Italian
Renaissance. That probably explains his dry, austere and limited vision
of the tarot.”; “She wrote that Dummett should have spent more time
looking for the ideas embedded in the cards than to ‘chase obscure card
games’. To name the capacity of the cards to embed deep performative
knowledge, Yates chose the word ‘hieroglyph.’”.
That sentence is the whole of the negative position, and it comes
with a date and a citation. So does the dispute it belongs to: Yates’s
review of Dummett’s The Game of Tarot in the New York
Review of Books for 19 February 1981, Dummett’s reply on 14 May
1981, and at the end of it the terminal condition:
“Rather than rehearse the intricacies of this exchange the issue
rested, finally, on Dummett’s appeal for, and openness towards, evidence
overturning his statement.”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part VIII (“The
Dummett-Yates controversy”). César Pedreros asks: “Why
is it that we cannot find books explicitly explaining the esoteric
significance of these images until French occultism emerged in the
eighteenth century? Were they destroyed? Were they simply never written?
Or was Michael Dummett right when he insisted that there was no such
thing as an esoteric tarot before the French occultists ‘discovered’ it
in the eighteenth century?”. Peter Adams,:
“Unfortunately, for many people it’s as though the clock became stuck
back in 1980 when Dummett published his study of the tarot as a game,
and has remained so ever since, so that merely referring to Dummett has
become a standard response on this issue — as though nothing has changed
in the intervening almost half century.”. “To be clear, the central
issue rests on Dummett’s claim that ‘no occult significance was attached
to the cards, nor any use made of them save for playing games, until the
intervention of Court de Gébelin in 1781.’”. “This topic formed the
subject of an exchange between Michael Dummett, a professor of logic and
expert on tarot games, and Frances Yates, a world-renowned expert on the
iconography and ideation of the Renaissance, in the context of Yates’s
review of Dummett’s The Game of Tarot.”; “Rather than rehearse
the intricacies of this exchange the issue rested, finally, on Dummett’s
appeal for, and openness towards, evidence overturning his statement.” .
“The evidence that neither Dummett nor Yates had access to in 1980 has
only become available over the last ten years or so, and it
fundamentally overturns Dummett’s supposition. Frances Yates was right
but lacked the specifics to establish her case.”. “The first piece of
evidence comes from the records of the Inquisition. A Venetian
courtesan, Isabella Bellochio, was stated to have ‘worshipped an image
of the devil by kneeling before it, with her hair loose, while
maintaining a lantern alight before it day and night … a light which
burned continuously in the kitchen in front of a devil and the tarocchi
…’” (ellipses in the original, the footnote there giving Martin, R.
(1989) Witchcraft and the Inquisition in Venice, 1550–1650,
163). “Surely this kind of dual-use of a portable, highly symbolic
source of imagery is only to be expected?”; “In this connection it is
interesting that the Sola-Busca’s trump XVII Ipeo is the only card to
show signs of wear on the paint surface. It appears to have been
thumb-marked by being repeatedly gripped or held at the mid-opposite
edges, which is not, of course, evidence of ritual use but it certainly
points towards prolonged and sustained contemplation of the image.”.
“Today, the evidence for the existence of occluded subtexts deliberately
hidden within the pre-Gébelin tarot is threefold. It comprises the
detailed analyses of the iconography of the Sola-Busca (Adams); the
early Tarot de Marseille (Poncet); and the Noblet Tarot de Marseille
(Appel).”; “So the answer to the question about the ‘missing evidence’
is that it was never missing. Some of it existed in official records;
the rest, by far the more impactful portion, was hidden, rather
artfully, in plain sight for these last five hundred years.”.
Christophe Poncet,: “I completely agree with Peter. The
cards themselves were the ‘missing evidence.’”; “Such writings do not
state ‘I have created a tarot deck that embodies my ideas and theurgical
practices,’ as the followers of Dummett seem to expect, because their
authors couldn’t express themselves openly.”; “He was a very intelligent
man. He was a professor of logic. And he knew a lot about philosophy,
but he seems not to have been familiar with the culture of the Italian
Renaissance. That probably explains his dry, austere and limited vision
of the tarot.”; “She wrote that Dummett should have spent more time
looking for the ideas embedded in the cards than to ‘chase obscure card
games’. To name the capacity of the cards to embed deep performative
knowledge, Yates chose the word ‘hieroglyph.’”.
Read that sentence twice, because it is the finding.
Dummett’s claim, as the book reports it, named its own
falsifier: it asked for the evidence that would refute it. That
is the opposite of a closed seat, and it is the property the owned cosmos asked of every frame and
almost never found.
Then the evidence, in two kinds. The first is a document: “The first
piece of evidence comes from the records of the Inquisition. A Venetian
courtesan, Isabella Bellochio, was stated to have ‘worshipped an image
of the devil by kneeling before it, with her hair loose, while
maintaining a lantern alight before it day and night … a light which
burned continuously in the kitchen in front of a devil and the tarocchi
…’”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part VIII (“The
Dummett-Yates controversy”). César Pedreros asks: “Why
is it that we cannot find books explicitly explaining the esoteric
significance of these images until French occultism emerged in the
eighteenth century? Were they destroyed? Were they simply never written?
Or was Michael Dummett right when he insisted that there was no such
thing as an esoteric tarot before the French occultists ‘discovered’ it
in the eighteenth century?”. Peter Adams,:
“Unfortunately, for many people it’s as though the clock became stuck
back in 1980 when Dummett published his study of the tarot as a game,
and has remained so ever since, so that merely referring to Dummett has
become a standard response on this issue — as though nothing has changed
in the intervening almost half century.”. “To be clear, the central
issue rests on Dummett’s claim that ‘no occult significance was attached
to the cards, nor any use made of them save for playing games, until the
intervention of Court de Gébelin in 1781.’”. “This topic formed the
subject of an exchange between Michael Dummett, a professor of logic and
expert on tarot games, and Frances Yates, a world-renowned expert on the
iconography and ideation of the Renaissance, in the context of Yates’s
review of Dummett’s The Game of Tarot.”; “Rather than rehearse
the intricacies of this exchange the issue rested, finally, on Dummett’s
appeal for, and openness towards, evidence overturning his statement.” .
“The evidence that neither Dummett nor Yates had access to in 1980 has
only become available over the last ten years or so, and it
fundamentally overturns Dummett’s supposition. Frances Yates was right
but lacked the specifics to establish her case.”. “The first piece of
evidence comes from the records of the Inquisition. A Venetian
courtesan, Isabella Bellochio, was stated to have ‘worshipped an image
of the devil by kneeling before it, with her hair loose, while
maintaining a lantern alight before it day and night … a light which
burned continuously in the kitchen in front of a devil and the tarocchi
…’” (ellipses in the original, the footnote there giving Martin, R.
(1989) Witchcraft and the Inquisition in Venice, 1550–1650,
163). “Surely this kind of dual-use of a portable, highly symbolic
source of imagery is only to be expected?”; “In this connection it is
interesting that the Sola-Busca’s trump XVII Ipeo is the only card to
show signs of wear on the paint surface. It appears to have been
thumb-marked by being repeatedly gripped or held at the mid-opposite
edges, which is not, of course, evidence of ritual use but it certainly
points towards prolonged and sustained contemplation of the image.”.
“Today, the evidence for the existence of occluded subtexts deliberately
hidden within the pre-Gébelin tarot is threefold. It comprises the
detailed analyses of the iconography of the Sola-Busca (Adams); the
early Tarot de Marseille (Poncet); and the Noblet Tarot de Marseille
(Appel).”; “So the answer to the question about the ‘missing evidence’
is that it was never missing. Some of it existed in official records;
the rest, by far the more impactful portion, was hidden, rather
artfully, in plain sight for these last five hundred years.”.
Christophe Poncet,: “I completely agree with Peter. The
cards themselves were the ‘missing evidence.’”; “Such writings do not
state ‘I have created a tarot deck that embodies my ideas and theurgical
practices,’ as the followers of Dummett seem to expect, because their
authors couldn’t express themselves openly.”; “He was a very intelligent
man. He was a professor of logic. And he knew a lot about philosophy,
but he seems not to have been familiar with the culture of the Italian
Renaissance. That probably explains his dry, austere and limited vision
of the tarot.”; “She wrote that Dummett should have spent more time
looking for the ideas embedded in the cards than to ‘chase obscure card
games’. To name the capacity of the cards to embed deep performative
knowledge, Yates chose the word ‘hieroglyph.’”. Adams reads it as use rather than
design, and then offers a physical observation, marking its
ceiling in the same breath: the card “appears to have been
thumb-marked … which is not, of course, evidence of ritual use but it
certainly points towards prolonged and sustained contemplation of the
image.”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part VIII (“The
Dummett-Yates controversy”). César Pedreros asks: “Why
is it that we cannot find books explicitly explaining the esoteric
significance of these images until French occultism emerged in the
eighteenth century? Were they destroyed? Were they simply never written?
Or was Michael Dummett right when he insisted that there was no such
thing as an esoteric tarot before the French occultists ‘discovered’ it
in the eighteenth century?”. Peter Adams,:
“Unfortunately, for many people it’s as though the clock became stuck
back in 1980 when Dummett published his study of the tarot as a game,
and has remained so ever since, so that merely referring to Dummett has
become a standard response on this issue — as though nothing has changed
in the intervening almost half century.”. “To be clear, the central
issue rests on Dummett’s claim that ‘no occult significance was attached
to the cards, nor any use made of them save for playing games, until the
intervention of Court de Gébelin in 1781.’”. “This topic formed the
subject of an exchange between Michael Dummett, a professor of logic and
expert on tarot games, and Frances Yates, a world-renowned expert on the
iconography and ideation of the Renaissance, in the context of Yates’s
review of Dummett’s The Game of Tarot.”; “Rather than rehearse
the intricacies of this exchange the issue rested, finally, on Dummett’s
appeal for, and openness towards, evidence overturning his statement.” .
“The evidence that neither Dummett nor Yates had access to in 1980 has
only become available over the last ten years or so, and it
fundamentally overturns Dummett’s supposition. Frances Yates was right
but lacked the specifics to establish her case.”. “The first piece of
evidence comes from the records of the Inquisition. A Venetian
courtesan, Isabella Bellochio, was stated to have ‘worshipped an image
of the devil by kneeling before it, with her hair loose, while
maintaining a lantern alight before it day and night … a light which
burned continuously in the kitchen in front of a devil and the tarocchi
…’” (ellipses in the original, the footnote there giving Martin, R.
(1989) Witchcraft and the Inquisition in Venice, 1550–1650,
163). “Surely this kind of dual-use of a portable, highly symbolic
source of imagery is only to be expected?”; “In this connection it is
interesting that the Sola-Busca’s trump XVII Ipeo is the only card to
show signs of wear on the paint surface. It appears to have been
thumb-marked by being repeatedly gripped or held at the mid-opposite
edges, which is not, of course, evidence of ritual use but it certainly
points towards prolonged and sustained contemplation of the image.”.
“Today, the evidence for the existence of occluded subtexts deliberately
hidden within the pre-Gébelin tarot is threefold. It comprises the
detailed analyses of the iconography of the Sola-Busca (Adams); the
early Tarot de Marseille (Poncet); and the Noblet Tarot de Marseille
(Appel).”; “So the answer to the question about the ‘missing evidence’
is that it was never missing. Some of it existed in official records;
the rest, by far the more impactful portion, was hidden, rather
artfully, in plain sight for these last five hundred years.”.
Christophe Poncet,: “I completely agree with Peter. The
cards themselves were the ‘missing evidence.’”; “Such writings do not
state ‘I have created a tarot deck that embodies my ideas and theurgical
practices,’ as the followers of Dummett seem to expect, because their
authors couldn’t express themselves openly.”; “He was a very intelligent
man. He was a professor of logic. And he knew a lot about philosophy,
but he seems not to have been familiar with the culture of the Italian
Renaissance. That probably explains his dry, austere and limited vision
of the tarot.”; “She wrote that Dummett should have spent more time
looking for the ideas embedded in the cards than to ‘chase obscure card
games’. To name the capacity of the cards to embed deep performative
knowledge, Yates chose the word ‘hieroglyph.’”. The second kind is
iconographic:
“Today, the evidence for the existence of occluded subtexts
deliberately hidden within the pre-Gébelin tarot is threefold. It
comprises the detailed analyses of the iconography of the Sola-Busca
(Adams); the early Tarot de Marseille (Poncet); and the Noblet Tarot de
Marseille (Appel).”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part VIII (“The
Dummett-Yates controversy”). César Pedreros asks: “Why
is it that we cannot find books explicitly explaining the esoteric
significance of these images until French occultism emerged in the
eighteenth century? Were they destroyed? Were they simply never written?
Or was Michael Dummett right when he insisted that there was no such
thing as an esoteric tarot before the French occultists ‘discovered’ it
in the eighteenth century?”. Peter Adams,:
“Unfortunately, for many people it’s as though the clock became stuck
back in 1980 when Dummett published his study of the tarot as a game,
and has remained so ever since, so that merely referring to Dummett has
become a standard response on this issue — as though nothing has changed
in the intervening almost half century.”. “To be clear, the central
issue rests on Dummett’s claim that ‘no occult significance was attached
to the cards, nor any use made of them save for playing games, until the
intervention of Court de Gébelin in 1781.’”. “This topic formed the
subject of an exchange between Michael Dummett, a professor of logic and
expert on tarot games, and Frances Yates, a world-renowned expert on the
iconography and ideation of the Renaissance, in the context of Yates’s
review of Dummett’s The Game of Tarot.”; “Rather than rehearse
the intricacies of this exchange the issue rested, finally, on Dummett’s
appeal for, and openness towards, evidence overturning his statement.” .
“The evidence that neither Dummett nor Yates had access to in 1980 has
only become available over the last ten years or so, and it
fundamentally overturns Dummett’s supposition. Frances Yates was right
but lacked the specifics to establish her case.”. “The first piece of
evidence comes from the records of the Inquisition. A Venetian
courtesan, Isabella Bellochio, was stated to have ‘worshipped an image
of the devil by kneeling before it, with her hair loose, while
maintaining a lantern alight before it day and night … a light which
burned continuously in the kitchen in front of a devil and the tarocchi
…’” (ellipses in the original, the footnote there giving Martin, R.
(1989) Witchcraft and the Inquisition in Venice, 1550–1650,
163). “Surely this kind of dual-use of a portable, highly symbolic
source of imagery is only to be expected?”; “In this connection it is
interesting that the Sola-Busca’s trump XVII Ipeo is the only card to
show signs of wear on the paint surface. It appears to have been
thumb-marked by being repeatedly gripped or held at the mid-opposite
edges, which is not, of course, evidence of ritual use but it certainly
points towards prolonged and sustained contemplation of the image.”.
“Today, the evidence for the existence of occluded subtexts deliberately
hidden within the pre-Gébelin tarot is threefold. It comprises the
detailed analyses of the iconography of the Sola-Busca (Adams); the
early Tarot de Marseille (Poncet); and the Noblet Tarot de Marseille
(Appel).”; “So the answer to the question about the ‘missing evidence’
is that it was never missing. Some of it existed in official records;
the rest, by far the more impactful portion, was hidden, rather
artfully, in plain sight for these last five hundred years.”.
Christophe Poncet,: “I completely agree with Peter. The
cards themselves were the ‘missing evidence.’”; “Such writings do not
state ‘I have created a tarot deck that embodies my ideas and theurgical
practices,’ as the followers of Dummett seem to expect, because their
authors couldn’t express themselves openly.”; “He was a very intelligent
man. He was a professor of logic. And he knew a lot about philosophy,
but he seems not to have been familiar with the culture of the Italian
Renaissance. That probably explains his dry, austere and limited vision
of the tarot.”; “She wrote that Dummett should have spent more time
looking for the ideas embedded in the cards than to ‘chase obscure card
games’. To name the capacity of the cards to embed deep performative
knowledge, Yates chose the word ‘hieroglyph.’”.
with Adams’s conclusion and Poncet’s echo: “So the answer to the
question about the ‘missing evidence’ is that it was never missing. Some
of it existed in official records; the rest, by far the more impactful
portion, was hidden, rather artfully, in plain sight for these last five
hundred years.”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part VIII (“The
Dummett-Yates controversy”). César Pedreros asks: “Why
is it that we cannot find books explicitly explaining the esoteric
significance of these images until French occultism emerged in the
eighteenth century? Were they destroyed? Were they simply never written?
Or was Michael Dummett right when he insisted that there was no such
thing as an esoteric tarot before the French occultists ‘discovered’ it
in the eighteenth century?”. Peter Adams,:
“Unfortunately, for many people it’s as though the clock became stuck
back in 1980 when Dummett published his study of the tarot as a game,
and has remained so ever since, so that merely referring to Dummett has
become a standard response on this issue — as though nothing has changed
in the intervening almost half century.”. “To be clear, the central
issue rests on Dummett’s claim that ‘no occult significance was attached
to the cards, nor any use made of them save for playing games, until the
intervention of Court de Gébelin in 1781.’”. “This topic formed the
subject of an exchange between Michael Dummett, a professor of logic and
expert on tarot games, and Frances Yates, a world-renowned expert on the
iconography and ideation of the Renaissance, in the context of Yates’s
review of Dummett’s The Game of Tarot.”; “Rather than rehearse
the intricacies of this exchange the issue rested, finally, on Dummett’s
appeal for, and openness towards, evidence overturning his statement.” .
“The evidence that neither Dummett nor Yates had access to in 1980 has
only become available over the last ten years or so, and it
fundamentally overturns Dummett’s supposition. Frances Yates was right
but lacked the specifics to establish her case.”. “The first piece of
evidence comes from the records of the Inquisition. A Venetian
courtesan, Isabella Bellochio, was stated to have ‘worshipped an image
of the devil by kneeling before it, with her hair loose, while
maintaining a lantern alight before it day and night … a light which
burned continuously in the kitchen in front of a devil and the tarocchi
…’” (ellipses in the original, the footnote there giving Martin, R.
(1989) Witchcraft and the Inquisition in Venice, 1550–1650,
163). “Surely this kind of dual-use of a portable, highly symbolic
source of imagery is only to be expected?”; “In this connection it is
interesting that the Sola-Busca’s trump XVII Ipeo is the only card to
show signs of wear on the paint surface. It appears to have been
thumb-marked by being repeatedly gripped or held at the mid-opposite
edges, which is not, of course, evidence of ritual use but it certainly
points towards prolonged and sustained contemplation of the image.”.
“Today, the evidence for the existence of occluded subtexts deliberately
hidden within the pre-Gébelin tarot is threefold. It comprises the
detailed analyses of the iconography of the Sola-Busca (Adams); the
early Tarot de Marseille (Poncet); and the Noblet Tarot de Marseille
(Appel).”; “So the answer to the question about the ‘missing evidence’
is that it was never missing. Some of it existed in official records;
the rest, by far the more impactful portion, was hidden, rather
artfully, in plain sight for these last five hundred years.”.
Christophe Poncet,: “I completely agree with Peter. The
cards themselves were the ‘missing evidence.’”; “Such writings do not
state ‘I have created a tarot deck that embodies my ideas and theurgical
practices,’ as the followers of Dummett seem to expect, because their
authors couldn’t express themselves openly.”; “He was a very intelligent
man. He was a professor of logic. And he knew a lot about philosophy,
but he seems not to have been familiar with the culture of the Italian
Renaissance. That probably explains his dry, austere and limited vision
of the tarot.”; “She wrote that Dummett should have spent more time
looking for the ideas embedded in the cards than to ‘chase obscure card
games’. To name the capacity of the cards to embed deep performative
knowledge, Yates chose the word ‘hieroglyph.’”. — “The cards themselves were the
‘missing evidence.’”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part VIII (“The
Dummett-Yates controversy”). César Pedreros asks: “Why
is it that we cannot find books explicitly explaining the esoteric
significance of these images until French occultism emerged in the
eighteenth century? Were they destroyed? Were they simply never written?
Or was Michael Dummett right when he insisted that there was no such
thing as an esoteric tarot before the French occultists ‘discovered’ it
in the eighteenth century?”. Peter Adams,:
“Unfortunately, for many people it’s as though the clock became stuck
back in 1980 when Dummett published his study of the tarot as a game,
and has remained so ever since, so that merely referring to Dummett has
become a standard response on this issue — as though nothing has changed
in the intervening almost half century.”. “To be clear, the central
issue rests on Dummett’s claim that ‘no occult significance was attached
to the cards, nor any use made of them save for playing games, until the
intervention of Court de Gébelin in 1781.’”. “This topic formed the
subject of an exchange between Michael Dummett, a professor of logic and
expert on tarot games, and Frances Yates, a world-renowned expert on the
iconography and ideation of the Renaissance, in the context of Yates’s
review of Dummett’s The Game of Tarot.”; “Rather than rehearse
the intricacies of this exchange the issue rested, finally, on Dummett’s
appeal for, and openness towards, evidence overturning his statement.” .
“The evidence that neither Dummett nor Yates had access to in 1980 has
only become available over the last ten years or so, and it
fundamentally overturns Dummett’s supposition. Frances Yates was right
but lacked the specifics to establish her case.”. “The first piece of
evidence comes from the records of the Inquisition. A Venetian
courtesan, Isabella Bellochio, was stated to have ‘worshipped an image
of the devil by kneeling before it, with her hair loose, while
maintaining a lantern alight before it day and night … a light which
burned continuously in the kitchen in front of a devil and the tarocchi
…’” (ellipses in the original, the footnote there giving Martin, R.
(1989) Witchcraft and the Inquisition in Venice, 1550–1650,
163). “Surely this kind of dual-use of a portable, highly symbolic
source of imagery is only to be expected?”; “In this connection it is
interesting that the Sola-Busca’s trump XVII Ipeo is the only card to
show signs of wear on the paint surface. It appears to have been
thumb-marked by being repeatedly gripped or held at the mid-opposite
edges, which is not, of course, evidence of ritual use but it certainly
points towards prolonged and sustained contemplation of the image.”.
“Today, the evidence for the existence of occluded subtexts deliberately
hidden within the pre-Gébelin tarot is threefold. It comprises the
detailed analyses of the iconography of the Sola-Busca (Adams); the
early Tarot de Marseille (Poncet); and the Noblet Tarot de Marseille
(Appel).”; “So the answer to the question about the ‘missing evidence’
is that it was never missing. Some of it existed in official records;
the rest, by far the more impactful portion, was hidden, rather
artfully, in plain sight for these last five hundred years.”.
Christophe Poncet,: “I completely agree with Peter. The
cards themselves were the ‘missing evidence.’”; “Such writings do not
state ‘I have created a tarot deck that embodies my ideas and theurgical
practices,’ as the followers of Dummett seem to expect, because their
authors couldn’t express themselves openly.”; “He was a very intelligent
man. He was a professor of logic. And he knew a lot about philosophy,
but he seems not to have been familiar with the culture of the Italian
Renaissance. That probably explains his dry, austere and limited vision
of the tarot.”; “She wrote that Dummett should have spent more time
looking for the ideas embedded in the cards than to ‘chase obscure card
games’. To name the capacity of the cards to embed deep performative
knowledge, Yates chose the word ‘hieroglyph.’”.
Now the reading, and it is not a verdict on the argument.
The strongest thing in this book is not that either side
wins. It is that the dispute is checkable. Every item in it is
a dated, third-party-readable object: Dummett’s The Game of
Tarot (1980); the review and reply of 1981; Decker, Depaulis and
Dummett’s A Wicked Pack of Cards (1996); Martin’s
Witchcraft and the Inquisition in Venice (1989); and the deck
itself, held by the Italian state since 2009 and, since the Brera’s
digitisation, available as images.Two Esoteric Tarots, Part VII (“Tarot
designers”), Peter Adams except where marked. “The
Sola-Busca appears to have been preserved within titled circles until
its purchase by the Italian state in 2009 — a period of some five
hundred years. Prior to that, to the best of my knowledge, it only
appeared in the public domain on four occasions.”; “The first was when
some of the cards were described in Count Cicognara’s memoire on
intaglio printmaking in 1831; the second, when art historian and curator
Arthur M. Hind arranged an exhibition of black and white photographic
images of the cards in the British Museum in 1907, and then included
some images of the cards in his catalogue of early Italian engravings.”
and “The fourth exposure of the cards was via a limited edition
reproduction of the entire deck by Wolfgang Mayer in 1998, though I can
find no further information as to how or why he undertook this
project.”. “I personally find his attribution convincing based upon
stylistic comparisons with the artist’s other works”. “Now, assuming
that De Marchi is right about the engraver’s identity, and given the
generally accepted dates during which he was active as an artist
(1472–1501), then a date for the engraving work roughly concurrent with
the ostensible production date of 1491 is a reasonable conjecture.”;
“Since the colouration of the deck’s figures corresponds to the
theurgical energies to which the ritual processes depicted within it
relate, then we can assume that the theurgical knowledge encoded in the
cards was also current at the d’Este court in the same time frame.”. The
political account: “The 1482–84 Salt War with Venice had essentially
bankrupted the state and destroyed a large portion of her agricultural
economy.”; “the presence of the initials ‘MS’ and the encoding of the
date 1491 points towards the Venetian patrician, Marin Sanudo, as their
intended recipient”; “The date encoded on trump XIIII Bocho (fig.16),
1491, also marked the date at which Ferrara received the first tranche
of reparations from Venice. A coincidence?” and “The cards may well have
served as a ‘reward’ for Sanudo’s support since they are precisely the
kind of unique, expensive, visually engaging artefact that he, a
celebrated bibliophile, would subsequently have displayed in his
house.”. And, in Christophe Poncet’s turn: “Ficino
takes the precaution of introducing each and every work of Plato with a
commentary.” . A person with no stake
in either outcome can read all of it. That is “a check that does not
benefit from the answer”, supplied not by a frame but by a
record — and one that cannot be converted into a
credential, the way the owned cosmos
found the checks of a named-endpoint frame can: “rites, lineages,
initiations, proofs of access”. Bibliographies do not convert, and the
object cannot be argued out of the museum.
The boundary of this reading has to be stated as plainly as
the finding. I have not read Dummett, Depaulis or Yates.
Everything above about what they held is a quotation or citation
given by this book, and the book’s own characterisation of them
— Poncet’s, in Part II — is a summary this post repeats as a summary:
“For them, the occult or esoteric tarot could only be an invention of
the French occultists.”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part II (“Occult,
esoteric and performative”), Christophe Poncet’s answer
to the end of the part. “So, at the end of the twentieth century, when
three scholars, Ronald Decker, Thierry Depaulis and Michael Dummett
wrote a book on the origins of the occult tarot, they simply set the
starting point of their history at the end of the eighteenth century.
For them, the occult or esoteric tarot could only be an invention of the
French occultists. Before that, they asserted, ever since its origins,
the tarot had only been a game of cards, with no other meanings or
usages of any kind.”. “In this way, two different decks of the fifteenth
century revealed themselves as spectacular examples of esotericism in
tarot, more than three hundred years before the earliest date previously
accepted by academic consensus.”. “To conclude on that point, I cannot
give you a definition of the esoteric or occult tarot. What I believe
for certain, however, is that, very early in the history of the tarot,
some decks had uses other than gaming.”. This post has not read
Dummett, Depaulis or Yates, and its account of what they held
is taken from this book and marked as the book’s. What can be verified here is the
shape and the addressability of the dispute — that its
items are named, dated and public — not its resolution, and not the
fairness of this book’s account of Dummett. The post takes no side.
Two further things the book puts in the record. Poncet’s
characterisation of Dummett — “He was a very intelligent man. … but he
seems not to have been familiar with the culture of the Italian
Renaissance”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part VIII (“The
Dummett-Yates controversy”). César Pedreros asks: “Why
is it that we cannot find books explicitly explaining the esoteric
significance of these images until French occultism emerged in the
eighteenth century? Were they destroyed? Were they simply never written?
Or was Michael Dummett right when he insisted that there was no such
thing as an esoteric tarot before the French occultists ‘discovered’ it
in the eighteenth century?”. Peter Adams,:
“Unfortunately, for many people it’s as though the clock became stuck
back in 1980 when Dummett published his study of the tarot as a game,
and has remained so ever since, so that merely referring to Dummett has
become a standard response on this issue — as though nothing has changed
in the intervening almost half century.”. “To be clear, the central
issue rests on Dummett’s claim that ‘no occult significance was attached
to the cards, nor any use made of them save for playing games, until the
intervention of Court de Gébelin in 1781.’”. “This topic formed the
subject of an exchange between Michael Dummett, a professor of logic and
expert on tarot games, and Frances Yates, a world-renowned expert on the
iconography and ideation of the Renaissance, in the context of Yates’s
review of Dummett’s The Game of Tarot.”; “Rather than rehearse
the intricacies of this exchange the issue rested, finally, on Dummett’s
appeal for, and openness towards, evidence overturning his statement.” .
“The evidence that neither Dummett nor Yates had access to in 1980 has
only become available over the last ten years or so, and it
fundamentally overturns Dummett’s supposition. Frances Yates was right
but lacked the specifics to establish her case.”. “The first piece of
evidence comes from the records of the Inquisition. A Venetian
courtesan, Isabella Bellochio, was stated to have ‘worshipped an image
of the devil by kneeling before it, with her hair loose, while
maintaining a lantern alight before it day and night … a light which
burned continuously in the kitchen in front of a devil and the tarocchi
…’” (ellipses in the original, the footnote there giving Martin, R.
(1989) Witchcraft and the Inquisition in Venice, 1550–1650,
163). “Surely this kind of dual-use of a portable, highly symbolic
source of imagery is only to be expected?”; “In this connection it is
interesting that the Sola-Busca’s trump XVII Ipeo is the only card to
show signs of wear on the paint surface. It appears to have been
thumb-marked by being repeatedly gripped or held at the mid-opposite
edges, which is not, of course, evidence of ritual use but it certainly
points towards prolonged and sustained contemplation of the image.”.
“Today, the evidence for the existence of occluded subtexts deliberately
hidden within the pre-Gébelin tarot is threefold. It comprises the
detailed analyses of the iconography of the Sola-Busca (Adams); the
early Tarot de Marseille (Poncet); and the Noblet Tarot de Marseille
(Appel).”; “So the answer to the question about the ‘missing evidence’
is that it was never missing. Some of it existed in official records;
the rest, by far the more impactful portion, was hidden, rather
artfully, in plain sight for these last five hundred years.”.
Christophe Poncet,: “I completely agree with Peter. The
cards themselves were the ‘missing evidence.’”; “Such writings do not
state ‘I have created a tarot deck that embodies my ideas and theurgical
practices,’ as the followers of Dummett seem to expect, because their
authors couldn’t express themselves openly.”; “He was a very intelligent
man. He was a professor of logic. And he knew a lot about philosophy,
but he seems not to have been familiar with the culture of the Italian
Renaissance. That probably explains his dry, austere and limited vision
of the tarot.”; “She wrote that Dummett should have spent more time
looking for the ideas embedded in the cards than to ‘chase obscure card
games’. To name the capacity of the cards to embed deep performative
knowledge, Yates chose the word ‘hieroglyph.’”. — is a claim about a scholar’s
competence made inside a conversation, quoted here as Poncet’s
characterisation, not as a finding. And Yates’s contribution is
given as a word choice: “To name the capacity of the cards to embed deep
performative knowledge, Yates chose the word ‘hieroglyph.’”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part VIII (“The
Dummett-Yates controversy”). César Pedreros asks: “Why
is it that we cannot find books explicitly explaining the esoteric
significance of these images until French occultism emerged in the
eighteenth century? Were they destroyed? Were they simply never written?
Or was Michael Dummett right when he insisted that there was no such
thing as an esoteric tarot before the French occultists ‘discovered’ it
in the eighteenth century?”. Peter Adams,:
“Unfortunately, for many people it’s as though the clock became stuck
back in 1980 when Dummett published his study of the tarot as a game,
and has remained so ever since, so that merely referring to Dummett has
become a standard response on this issue — as though nothing has changed
in the intervening almost half century.”. “To be clear, the central
issue rests on Dummett’s claim that ‘no occult significance was attached
to the cards, nor any use made of them save for playing games, until the
intervention of Court de Gébelin in 1781.’”. “This topic formed the
subject of an exchange between Michael Dummett, a professor of logic and
expert on tarot games, and Frances Yates, a world-renowned expert on the
iconography and ideation of the Renaissance, in the context of Yates’s
review of Dummett’s The Game of Tarot.”; “Rather than rehearse
the intricacies of this exchange the issue rested, finally, on Dummett’s
appeal for, and openness towards, evidence overturning his statement.” .
“The evidence that neither Dummett nor Yates had access to in 1980 has
only become available over the last ten years or so, and it
fundamentally overturns Dummett’s supposition. Frances Yates was right
but lacked the specifics to establish her case.”. “The first piece of
evidence comes from the records of the Inquisition. A Venetian
courtesan, Isabella Bellochio, was stated to have ‘worshipped an image
of the devil by kneeling before it, with her hair loose, while
maintaining a lantern alight before it day and night … a light which
burned continuously in the kitchen in front of a devil and the tarocchi
…’” (ellipses in the original, the footnote there giving Martin, R.
(1989) Witchcraft and the Inquisition in Venice, 1550–1650,
163). “Surely this kind of dual-use of a portable, highly symbolic
source of imagery is only to be expected?”; “In this connection it is
interesting that the Sola-Busca’s trump XVII Ipeo is the only card to
show signs of wear on the paint surface. It appears to have been
thumb-marked by being repeatedly gripped or held at the mid-opposite
edges, which is not, of course, evidence of ritual use but it certainly
points towards prolonged and sustained contemplation of the image.”.
“Today, the evidence for the existence of occluded subtexts deliberately
hidden within the pre-Gébelin tarot is threefold. It comprises the
detailed analyses of the iconography of the Sola-Busca (Adams); the
early Tarot de Marseille (Poncet); and the Noblet Tarot de Marseille
(Appel).”; “So the answer to the question about the ‘missing evidence’
is that it was never missing. Some of it existed in official records;
the rest, by far the more impactful portion, was hidden, rather
artfully, in plain sight for these last five hundred years.”.
Christophe Poncet,: “I completely agree with Peter. The
cards themselves were the ‘missing evidence.’”; “Such writings do not
state ‘I have created a tarot deck that embodies my ideas and theurgical
practices,’ as the followers of Dummett seem to expect, because their
authors couldn’t express themselves openly.”; “He was a very intelligent
man. He was a professor of logic. And he knew a lot about philosophy,
but he seems not to have been familiar with the culture of the Italian
Renaissance. That probably explains his dry, austere and limited vision
of the tarot.”; “She wrote that Dummett should have spent more time
looking for the ideas embedded in the cards than to ‘chase obscure card
games’. To name the capacity of the cards to embed deep performative
knowledge, Yates chose the word ‘hieroglyph.’”. The word is the argument: a
Renaissance hieroglyph is an image that embeds ideas and
power.
5. The lineage, and
the warrant of an artwork
The environment’s inventory has a
lever for this: “A pre-certified frame — the warrant is issued
by the host, not the group, and scrutiny reads as
bigotry.” In the case studies the host was a culture and the
frame was a teacher’s. Here the warrant is claimed for an
artwork, by two named living researchers, and the certifying
authority is a name and a tradition. Same lever, different carrier.
Adams lays out the lineage in Part VI. Its content is a transfer:
“Giovanni Aurispa returned from Constantinople in 1423 and again in 1427
… bringing hundreds of Hellenistic texts with him”;Two Esoteric Tarots, Part VI (“The Hellenistic
revolution and the second renaissance”), Peter Adams,
throughout. “Uniquely, the Sola-Busca appears to have embodied the
actual ritual processes for performing theurgy.”. “Giovanni Aurispa
returned from Constantinople in 1423 and again in 1427, on each occasion
bringing hundreds of Hellenistic texts with him. Amongst these texts
were the complete works of Plato, Proclus, Plotinus, and most of
Iamblichus.”; “Their significance — especially the works of Proclus and
Iamblichus — was the performativity that was fundamental to their
approach as practicing polytheistic Hellenists.”; “So inspiring were
these ideas that they triggered a second Hellenistic Renaissance that
fundamentally influenced the subsequent course of European culture for
the next three centuries.”. “In addition, this alternative spiritual
path was under-written by two sources of authority: firstly, that
accorded to ancient texts which were conceived as emerging from a fount
of pristine wisdom (prisca theologia) at a time close to the
act of creation, and were thereby thought to be imbued with far greater
depth, wisdom and verisimilitude” (the italics run is closed up here).
“That said, the fact that these beliefs threatened to undermine the
institutional power of church and state meant that they could only be
preserved by being occluded within other media. From the proactive
perspective enjoined by theurgists, such as Proclus, the influence of
higher order energies, or deities, could be embodied via their
geometrical forms in artworks that would, henceforth, emanate their
distinctive presence into the world.”.
Plethon is present in the Italian city states; the result is “a second
Hellenistic Renaissance”, grounded in practice rather than doctrine,
since “their significance — especially the works of Proclus and
Iamblichus — was the performativity that was fundamental to their
approach as practicing polytheistic Hellenists.”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part VI (“The Hellenistic
revolution and the second renaissance”), Peter Adams,
throughout. “Uniquely, the Sola-Busca appears to have embodied the
actual ritual processes for performing theurgy.”. “Giovanni Aurispa
returned from Constantinople in 1423 and again in 1427, on each occasion
bringing hundreds of Hellenistic texts with him. Amongst these texts
were the complete works of Plato, Proclus, Plotinus, and most of
Iamblichus.”; “Their significance — especially the works of Proclus and
Iamblichus — was the performativity that was fundamental to their
approach as practicing polytheistic Hellenists.”; “So inspiring were
these ideas that they triggered a second Hellenistic Renaissance that
fundamentally influenced the subsequent course of European culture for
the next three centuries.”. “In addition, this alternative spiritual
path was under-written by two sources of authority: firstly, that
accorded to ancient texts which were conceived as emerging from a fount
of pristine wisdom (prisca theologia) at a time close to the
act of creation, and were thereby thought to be imbued with far greater
depth, wisdom and verisimilitude” (the italics run is closed up here).
“That said, the fact that these beliefs threatened to undermine the
institutional power of church and state meant that they could only be
preserved by being occluded within other media. From the proactive
perspective enjoined by theurgists, such as Proclus, the influence of
higher order energies, or deities, could be embodied via their
geometrical forms in artworks that would, henceforth, emanate their
distinctive presence into the world.”.
Then the mechanism — the bridge that would make a card
operative at all:
“The fact that these beliefs threatened to undermine the
institutional power of church and state meant that they could only be
preserved by being occluded within other media. From the proactive
perspective enjoined by theurgists, such as Proclus, the influence of
higher order energies, or deities, could be embodied via their
geometrical forms in artworks that would, henceforth, emanate their
distinctive presence into the world.”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part VI (“The Hellenistic
revolution and the second renaissance”), Peter Adams,
throughout. “Uniquely, the Sola-Busca appears to have embodied the
actual ritual processes for performing theurgy.”. “Giovanni Aurispa
returned from Constantinople in 1423 and again in 1427, on each occasion
bringing hundreds of Hellenistic texts with him. Amongst these texts
were the complete works of Plato, Proclus, Plotinus, and most of
Iamblichus.”; “Their significance — especially the works of Proclus and
Iamblichus — was the performativity that was fundamental to their
approach as practicing polytheistic Hellenists.”; “So inspiring were
these ideas that they triggered a second Hellenistic Renaissance that
fundamentally influenced the subsequent course of European culture for
the next three centuries.”. “In addition, this alternative spiritual
path was under-written by two sources of authority: firstly, that
accorded to ancient texts which were conceived as emerging from a fount
of pristine wisdom (prisca theologia) at a time close to the
act of creation, and were thereby thought to be imbued with far greater
depth, wisdom and verisimilitude” (the italics run is closed up here).
“That said, the fact that these beliefs threatened to undermine the
institutional power of church and state meant that they could only be
preserved by being occluded within other media. From the proactive
perspective enjoined by theurgists, such as Proclus, the influence of
higher order energies, or deities, could be embodied via their
geometrical forms in artworks that would, henceforth, emanate their
distinctive presence into the world.”.
And the warrant’s own shape, named with its Latin term: the texts
“were conceived as emerging from a fount of pristine wisdom (prisca
theologia) at a time close to the act of creation, and were thereby
thought to be imbued with far greater depth, wisdom and
verisimilitude”.Two Esoteric Tarots, Part VI (“The Hellenistic
revolution and the second renaissance”), Peter Adams,
throughout. “Uniquely, the Sola-Busca appears to have embodied the
actual ritual processes for performing theurgy.”. “Giovanni Aurispa
returned from Constantinople in 1423 and again in 1427, on each occasion
bringing hundreds of Hellenistic texts with him. Amongst these texts
were the complete works of Plato, Proclus, Plotinus, and most of
Iamblichus.”; “Their significance — especially the works of Proclus and
Iamblichus — was the performativity that was fundamental to their
approach as practicing polytheistic Hellenists.”; “So inspiring were
these ideas that they triggered a second Hellenistic Renaissance that
fundamentally influenced the subsequent course of European culture for
the next three centuries.”. “In addition, this alternative spiritual
path was under-written by two sources of authority: firstly, that
accorded to ancient texts which were conceived as emerging from a fount
of pristine wisdom (prisca theologia) at a time close to the
act of creation, and were thereby thought to be imbued with far greater
depth, wisdom and verisimilitude” (the italics run is closed up here).
“That said, the fact that these beliefs threatened to undermine the
institutional power of church and state meant that they could only be
preserved by being occluded within other media. From the proactive
perspective enjoined by theurgists, such as Proclus, the influence of
higher order energies, or deities, could be embodied via their
geometrical forms in artworks that would, henceforth, emanate their
distinctive presence into the world.”.
The structural point is this: the authority being invoked is
also the object of the study. Ficino is both the evidence and
the credential. In the certified
frame the warrant arrived from a host culture that had not
scrutinised the teacher; in Star.Ships it was self-issued in
the first person. Here the researcher’s subject
supplies the warrant — the one warrant no amount of scrolling in the
source will separate from the source.
And there is a brake to apply immediately, which is this
series’ own. The lever the
environment named is about predation — the price a
predator does not have to pay. There is no predator in this book: two
researchers have written about two decks, and nobody is recruiting
anyone. What the blog owes is the lever’s shape and not
its charge — not “is this being used on someone” but
“who issued this warrant, and would the issuer recognise the use it is
being put to”. Applied here the second question has a checkable answer,
because Ficino’s own position on planetary influence is in the text:
“I don’t think the planetary divinities mentioned in most of Ficino’s
astrological writings, and thus the grid I just described for the Tarot
de Marseille, should be understood as referring to celestial bodies
acting on things and people.”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part X (“The seven
planets”). Christophe Poncet: “In Ficino’s commentary
on Plato’s Timaeus, there is a passage, about one page long, in
which the soul is compared to a triple septenary, so a three times seven
structure. … The seven planets all appear in it, and we understand that
the structure of the soul has three levels — the superior, the inferior
and the intermediary — and seven columns, one for each planet of the
Ptolemaic system … The sentences in which the planets are mentioned make
no sense in themselves. However, when I tried to compare these sentences
with the trumps of the Tarot de Marseille, I realised they were puns or
wordplays or clues hinting at the arcana. A three times seven grid has
twenty-one cells, so one for each arcanum of the tarot, given that two
of the trumps form a single arcanum: the one that has no name
(Arcanum XIII) and the one that has no number (The
Fool), forming together the inferior arcanum of Saturn. In this
way, the grid could be seen as the hidden structure of the Tarot de
Marseille, within which all the trumps could be ordered.”. “To give a
precise answer to the question, I don’t think the planetary divinities
mentioned in most of Ficino’s astrological writings, and thus the grid I
just described for the Tarot de Marseille, should be understood as
referring to celestial bodies acting on things and people. For him, the
planets have no influence on the sublunar world. They are signs that
reveal the universe … In the Tarot de Marseille, astrological allusions
should most probably be seen as analogies put at the service of the
description of souls.”. Peter Adams replies: “Yes, it’s
a much more minimalistic situation with the Sola-Busca because the only
celestial … and sidereal bodies … that can be discerned, are all
malefic.”
For Ficino, on this account, “the planets have no influence on the
sublunar world”, and astrological allusions are “analogies put at the
service of the description of souls.”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part X (“The seven
planets”). Christophe Poncet: “In Ficino’s commentary
on Plato’s Timaeus, there is a passage, about one page long, in
which the soul is compared to a triple septenary, so a three times seven
structure. … The seven planets all appear in it, and we understand that
the structure of the soul has three levels — the superior, the inferior
and the intermediary — and seven columns, one for each planet of the
Ptolemaic system … The sentences in which the planets are mentioned make
no sense in themselves. However, when I tried to compare these sentences
with the trumps of the Tarot de Marseille, I realised they were puns or
wordplays or clues hinting at the arcana. A three times seven grid has
twenty-one cells, so one for each arcanum of the tarot, given that two
of the trumps form a single arcanum: the one that has no name
(Arcanum XIII) and the one that has no number (The
Fool), forming together the inferior arcanum of Saturn. In this
way, the grid could be seen as the hidden structure of the Tarot de
Marseille, within which all the trumps could be ordered.”. “To give a
precise answer to the question, I don’t think the planetary divinities
mentioned in most of Ficino’s astrological writings, and thus the grid I
just described for the Tarot de Marseille, should be understood as
referring to celestial bodies acting on things and people. For him, the
planets have no influence on the sublunar world. They are signs that
reveal the universe … In the Tarot de Marseille, astrological allusions
should most probably be seen as analogies put at the service of the
description of souls.”. Peter Adams replies: “Yes, it’s
a much more minimalistic situation with the Sola-Busca because the only
celestial … and sidereal bodies … that can be discerned, are all
malefic.”
So the warrant and the claim are not the same claim:
Ficino certifies the design, not the operation.
Adams’s Sola-Busca, by contrast, is explicitly a matter of forces and
their timing — “Mars, Saturn and chthonic Mercury under the influence of
the most malefic of fixed stars, Algol”, and “a technocratic,
astrologically-driven vision of the universe as a collection of
manipulable forces.”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part IX (“Cyphers and
time”). Christophe Poncet: “If we think of the game as
a combinatorial system, you need every part to make it work. So, it’s a
complete system and each part has its function.”. “My research shows
that the Tarot de Marseille was designed between 1470 and 1475. The
Sola-Busca was probably created about ten years later in reaction to
Ficino’s deck, proposing in similar ways an opposite ideology.”; and, on
Ficino’s doctrine of the incarnate soul: “For him, the journey of the
soul during physical life necessarily leads to a state of madness. The
soul becomes crazed when it is incarnated because, being immortal, her
natural state is not to be imprisoned in a body, it is to be united with
God.”. Peter Adams: “What I perceive with respect to
the Sola-Busca is that each of the trumps, and certain of the suit
cards, form an elaborate cypher composed of some combination of
historical or literary references, astro-alchemical allusions and ritual
postures, gestures and magical implements. That being said, the recovery
of the ‘sense’ — the cards’ deeper narratives — requires that these
figures be grouped together in specific combinations.”. On time: “These
operations depend upon drawing in very specific forces — the energies of
Mars, Saturn and chthonic Mercury under the influence of the most
malefic of fixed stars, Algol — at the time of their maximum strength.
There’s a high degree of precision in the calculations required to
achieve this. You would need to be an astrologer to make all of the
calculations … All of the other operations would require equally precise
timing — the collection of the menstruum, the preparation of the ritual
space, garments, implements and the person of the Mage. With the
Sola-Busca, therefore, we encounter time in its most instrumental
sense”. “The whole operation functions like a very complicated,
intricate timepiece … In other words, we find ourselves at a very
instrumental end of the spiritual spectrum, one more usually associated
with goetia than with classical theurgy. This is a technocratic,
astrologically-driven vision of the universe as a collection of
manipulable forces. Ritually, the deck does not pose a question, it
instructs us on how to draw this power down in its rawest form and
manifest it into the external world. It is highly disciplined — which
is, of course, a highly Saturnian quality.”.
What would count as evidence for the continuity
claim is also stated, as an absence, in the exact form a
document would have had to take: “Such writings do not state ‘I have
created a tarot deck that embodies my ideas and theurgical practices,’
as the followers of Dummett seem to expect, because their authors
couldn’t express themselves openly.”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part VIII (“The
Dummett-Yates controversy”). César Pedreros asks: “Why
is it that we cannot find books explicitly explaining the esoteric
significance of these images until French occultism emerged in the
eighteenth century? Were they destroyed? Were they simply never written?
Or was Michael Dummett right when he insisted that there was no such
thing as an esoteric tarot before the French occultists ‘discovered’ it
in the eighteenth century?”. Peter Adams,:
“Unfortunately, for many people it’s as though the clock became stuck
back in 1980 when Dummett published his study of the tarot as a game,
and has remained so ever since, so that merely referring to Dummett has
become a standard response on this issue — as though nothing has changed
in the intervening almost half century.”. “To be clear, the central
issue rests on Dummett’s claim that ‘no occult significance was attached
to the cards, nor any use made of them save for playing games, until the
intervention of Court de Gébelin in 1781.’”. “This topic formed the
subject of an exchange between Michael Dummett, a professor of logic and
expert on tarot games, and Frances Yates, a world-renowned expert on the
iconography and ideation of the Renaissance, in the context of Yates’s
review of Dummett’s The Game of Tarot.”; “Rather than rehearse
the intricacies of this exchange the issue rested, finally, on Dummett’s
appeal for, and openness towards, evidence overturning his statement.” .
“The evidence that neither Dummett nor Yates had access to in 1980 has
only become available over the last ten years or so, and it
fundamentally overturns Dummett’s supposition. Frances Yates was right
but lacked the specifics to establish her case.”. “The first piece of
evidence comes from the records of the Inquisition. A Venetian
courtesan, Isabella Bellochio, was stated to have ‘worshipped an image
of the devil by kneeling before it, with her hair loose, while
maintaining a lantern alight before it day and night … a light which
burned continuously in the kitchen in front of a devil and the tarocchi
…’” (ellipses in the original, the footnote there giving Martin, R.
(1989) Witchcraft and the Inquisition in Venice, 1550–1650,
163). “Surely this kind of dual-use of a portable, highly symbolic
source of imagery is only to be expected?”; “In this connection it is
interesting that the Sola-Busca’s trump XVII Ipeo is the only card to
show signs of wear on the paint surface. It appears to have been
thumb-marked by being repeatedly gripped or held at the mid-opposite
edges, which is not, of course, evidence of ritual use but it certainly
points towards prolonged and sustained contemplation of the image.”.
“Today, the evidence for the existence of occluded subtexts deliberately
hidden within the pre-Gébelin tarot is threefold. It comprises the
detailed analyses of the iconography of the Sola-Busca (Adams); the
early Tarot de Marseille (Poncet); and the Noblet Tarot de Marseille
(Appel).”; “So the answer to the question about the ‘missing evidence’
is that it was never missing. Some of it existed in official records;
the rest, by far the more impactful portion, was hidden, rather
artfully, in plain sight for these last five hundred years.”.
Christophe Poncet,: “I completely agree with Peter. The
cards themselves were the ‘missing evidence.’”; “Such writings do not
state ‘I have created a tarot deck that embodies my ideas and theurgical
practices,’ as the followers of Dummett seem to expect, because their
authors couldn’t express themselves openly.”; “He was a very intelligent
man. He was a professor of logic. And he knew a lot about philosophy,
but he seems not to have been familiar with the culture of the Italian
Renaissance. That probably explains his dry, austere and limited vision
of the tarot.”; “She wrote that Dummett should have spent more time
looking for the ideas embedded in the cards than to ‘chase obscure card
games’. To name the capacity of the cards to embed deep performative
knowledge, Yates chose the word ‘hieroglyph.’”. That has a shape this
series has seen: the document that cannot exist because writing it was
dangerous is the document that cannot falsify anything. It is
also a historically ordinary situation — Renaissance
heretics were burned — and this post does not adjudicate between the two
readings of the absence. Adams then reports the modern tradition in the
first person — “Twenty-five years ago, I met a tarot teacher who
enlightened me as to the existence of an initiatory tradition in
relation to the tarot … accompanied by ‘signs following’ that serve to
confirm the validity of the transmission”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part II, section “On the
Performative”, Peter Adams: “My own conclusion is that
the ‘esoteric tarot’ rests fully upon a performative occasion; one in
which there is a distinct experience of some degree of automatism —
whether conceived as entering a state of flow, intuition or external
facilitation. Therein, for a space of time, the reader and the reading
appear to occupy two different worlds, the reading appears to have taken
on a life, and a direction, of its own.”. “Such is the archetypal nature
of its imagery, the tarot has the capacity to act as a container for a
broad range of spiritual impulses.”. “Twenty-five years ago, I met a
tarot teacher who enlightened me as to the existence of an initiatory
tradition in relation to the tarot (whether bestowed ‘in spirit’ or
through a lineage holder) and accompanied by ‘signs following’ that
serve to confirm the validity of the transmission. On occasion, tarot
rituals may be empowered by such a tradition. This is seldom spoken of,
or even alluded to, within the vast corpus of tarot-related
literature.”. César Pedreros opened the part: “Since
we’re framing our conversation with the term ‘esoteric tarot’ it is
important to address what we understand by esoteric”. —
and the check it names, signs following, is exactly the class
of check the owned cosmos found
converts tests into credentials.
6. Counterweights, in the body
First: the strongest language in the book is not the
researchers’. It is the convenor’s, and the counts make it
plain. The Foreword is 1.8 per cent of the
text. In it are the sentences quoted at §3: “firmly maintained”,
“shattered that consensus”, “unequivocally challenges”, “It is evident
that”. Across the whole text the word “unequivocally”
occurs once, and it is there.Reported as a search result, and scoped to the text of
this edition. Case-insensitive counts over the book’s text.
Length: the Foreword is 1.8 per cent
of the text. Strong epistemic markers: “unequivocally”
occurs 1 time in the text, inside the Foreword;
“firmly” 3 times (in the Foreword, and twice
elsewhere); “shattered” 2 (in the Foreword, of the
scholarly consensus, and once more, of the medieval worldview);
“evident” 4 (one in the Foreword, three elsewhere).
Hedge markers, case-insensitive substring counts across the
whole text, the Foreword’s count in brackets: “probably” 20
(0), “seems” 10 (0), “likely” 8 (0), “may have” 7 (0), “apparently” 4
(0), “perhaps” 3 (0), “to my mind” 2 (0), “I guess” 1 (0), “I gather” 1
(0), “tentatively” 1 (0), “My suggestion” 1 (0), “conjecture” 1 (0),
“possible” 4 (0), “possibility” 1 (0) — 64 across the text, 0 in
the Foreword. Safeguard: “safeguard” returns
1 hit, inside “safeguarded”, in the convenor’s question
about transmitting knowledge. Pace: “pace” returns
6 hits and 0 as a word of its own;
every hit is inside “space” — “for a space of time”, “the ritual space”
twice, “twenty-two spaces”, “this turbulent political space” and “the
efficacious space of your own dreams”. Clinical and risk
vocabulary returning 0 hits: danger, warn, warning, doctor,
therap-, therapist, psychiatr-, psychiatric, psychiatry, psychotic,
clinical, hospital, crisis, suicid-, mental health, breakdown, seek
help, professional help, self-harm, mentor, dose, safety, ethic.
Near-misses: “risk” 1 (the historical
risk run by Renaissance practitioners); “precaution” 1
(Ficino’s commentary habit); “caution” 0 as a word of
its own and 1 as a substring of “precaution”; “madness”
2 (Ficino’s doctrine that the incarnate soul’s journey
“necessarily leads to a state of madness”, and an index entry);
“careful” 5 (all five about examining images or texts);
“psycho” 3, all inside “metempsychosis”; “supervis”
1 (Prisciani’s “design and supervision” of a fresco
cycle); “discipline” 2 (the Quadrivium, and “It is
highly disciplined”); “purif” 2 (of the soul);
“meditat” 8, of which 5 are the title of Tomberg’s
Meditations on the Tarot or references to it, 2 are “divination
and meditation”/“divination, meditative or ritual use”, and 1 is
“meditative ritual”. The word “third” occurs
1 time in the text (“thirdly” in Adams’s four decoding
steps) and does not appear in the third element of the deck’s four
public appearances. A search shows only what it indexes, so every count
here is scoped to the text of this edition.
Now the other half: in the rest of the text, a test list of fourteen
hedge markers returns 64 occurrences and
0 of them fall in the Foreword —
“probably” 20 times, “seems” 10,
“likely” 8, “may have” 7,
“apparently” 4, “perhaps” 3,
“to my mind” twice, and the singletons “I
guess”, “I gather”,
“tentatively”, “My suggestion” and
“conjecture”.Reported as a search result, and scoped to the text of
this edition. Case-insensitive counts over the book’s text.
Length: the Foreword is 1.8 per cent
of the text. Strong epistemic markers: “unequivocally”
occurs 1 time in the text, inside the Foreword;
“firmly” 3 times (in the Foreword, and twice
elsewhere); “shattered” 2 (in the Foreword, of the
scholarly consensus, and once more, of the medieval worldview);
“evident” 4 (one in the Foreword, three elsewhere).
Hedge markers, case-insensitive substring counts across the
whole text, the Foreword’s count in brackets: “probably” 20
(0), “seems” 10 (0), “likely” 8 (0), “may have” 7 (0), “apparently” 4
(0), “perhaps” 3 (0), “to my mind” 2 (0), “I guess” 1 (0), “I gather” 1
(0), “tentatively” 1 (0), “My suggestion” 1 (0), “conjecture” 1 (0),
“possible” 4 (0), “possibility” 1 (0) — 64 across the text, 0 in
the Foreword. Safeguard: “safeguard” returns
1 hit, inside “safeguarded”, in the convenor’s question
about transmitting knowledge. Pace: “pace” returns
6 hits and 0 as a word of its own;
every hit is inside “space” — “for a space of time”, “the ritual space”
twice, “twenty-two spaces”, “this turbulent political space” and “the
efficacious space of your own dreams”. Clinical and risk
vocabulary returning 0 hits: danger, warn, warning, doctor,
therap-, therapist, psychiatr-, psychiatric, psychiatry, psychotic,
clinical, hospital, crisis, suicid-, mental health, breakdown, seek
help, professional help, self-harm, mentor, dose, safety, ethic.
Near-misses: “risk” 1 (the historical
risk run by Renaissance practitioners); “precaution” 1
(Ficino’s commentary habit); “caution” 0 as a word of
its own and 1 as a substring of “precaution”; “madness”
2 (Ficino’s doctrine that the incarnate soul’s journey
“necessarily leads to a state of madness”, and an index entry);
“careful” 5 (all five about examining images or texts);
“psycho” 3, all inside “metempsychosis”; “supervis”
1 (Prisciani’s “design and supervision” of a fresco
cycle); “discipline” 2 (the Quadrivium, and “It is
highly disciplined”); “purif” 2 (of the soul);
“meditat” 8, of which 5 are the title of Tomberg’s
Meditations on the Tarot or references to it, 2 are “divination
and meditation”/“divination, meditative or ritual use”, and 1 is
“meditative ritual”. The word “third” occurs
1 time in the text (“thirdly” in Adams’s four decoding
steps) and does not appear in the third element of the deck’s four
public appearances. A search shows only what it indexes, so every count
here is scoped to the text of this edition. That is not deception:
a foreword is a recommendation, written in the register of
recommendation. But the paragraph with the least hedging in the
book is the one a reader is most likely to quote.
Second: the dating rests on named conditionals, and the book
names them. The deck’s date is not read off a document. It runs
an engraver attribution (De Marchi’s, with Adams adding “I personally
find his attribution convincing based upon stylistic comparisons”),Two Esoteric Tarots, Part VII (“Tarot
designers”), Peter Adams except where marked. “The
Sola-Busca appears to have been preserved within titled circles until
its purchase by the Italian state in 2009 — a period of some five
hundred years. Prior to that, to the best of my knowledge, it only
appeared in the public domain on four occasions.”; “The first was when
some of the cards were described in Count Cicognara’s memoire on
intaglio printmaking in 1831; the second, when art historian and curator
Arthur M. Hind arranged an exhibition of black and white photographic
images of the cards in the British Museum in 1907, and then included
some images of the cards in his catalogue of early Italian engravings.”
and “The fourth exposure of the cards was via a limited edition
reproduction of the entire deck by Wolfgang Mayer in 1998, though I can
find no further information as to how or why he undertook this
project.”. “I personally find his attribution convincing based upon
stylistic comparisons with the artist’s other works”. “Now, assuming
that De Marchi is right about the engraver’s identity, and given the
generally accepted dates during which he was active as an artist
(1472–1501), then a date for the engraving work roughly concurrent with
the ostensible production date of 1491 is a reasonable conjecture.”;
“Since the colouration of the deck’s figures corresponds to the
theurgical energies to which the ritual processes depicted within it
relate, then we can assume that the theurgical knowledge encoded in the
cards was also current at the d’Este court in the same time frame.”. The
political account: “The 1482–84 Salt War with Venice had essentially
bankrupted the state and destroyed a large portion of her agricultural
economy.”; “the presence of the initials ‘MS’ and the encoding of the
date 1491 points towards the Venetian patrician, Marin Sanudo, as their
intended recipient”; “The date encoded on trump XIIII Bocho (fig.16),
1491, also marked the date at which Ferrara received the first tranche
of reparations from Venice. A coincidence?” and “The cards may well have
served as a ‘reward’ for Sanudo’s support since they are precisely the
kind of unique, expensive, visually engaging artefact that he, a
celebrated bibliophile, would subsequently have displayed in his
house.”. And, in Christophe Poncet’s turn: “Ficino
takes the precaution of introducing each and every work of Plato with a
commentary.” . a date string “encoded” on trump
XIIII Bocho and connected to a reparations payment, and the c.1490 or
1491 window — “assuming that De Marchi is right … a reasonable
conjecture.”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part VII (“Tarot
designers”), Peter Adams except where marked. “The
Sola-Busca appears to have been preserved within titled circles until
its purchase by the Italian state in 2009 — a period of some five
hundred years. Prior to that, to the best of my knowledge, it only
appeared in the public domain on four occasions.”; “The first was when
some of the cards were described in Count Cicognara’s memoire on
intaglio printmaking in 1831; the second, when art historian and curator
Arthur M. Hind arranged an exhibition of black and white photographic
images of the cards in the British Museum in 1907, and then included
some images of the cards in his catalogue of early Italian engravings.”
and “The fourth exposure of the cards was via a limited edition
reproduction of the entire deck by Wolfgang Mayer in 1998, though I can
find no further information as to how or why he undertook this
project.”. “I personally find his attribution convincing based upon
stylistic comparisons with the artist’s other works”. “Now, assuming
that De Marchi is right about the engraver’s identity, and given the
generally accepted dates during which he was active as an artist
(1472–1501), then a date for the engraving work roughly concurrent with
the ostensible production date of 1491 is a reasonable conjecture.”;
“Since the colouration of the deck’s figures corresponds to the
theurgical energies to which the ritual processes depicted within it
relate, then we can assume that the theurgical knowledge encoded in the
cards was also current at the d’Este court in the same time frame.”. The
political account: “The 1482–84 Salt War with Venice had essentially
bankrupted the state and destroyed a large portion of her agricultural
economy.”; “the presence of the initials ‘MS’ and the encoding of the
date 1491 points towards the Venetian patrician, Marin Sanudo, as their
intended recipient”; “The date encoded on trump XIIII Bocho (fig.16),
1491, also marked the date at which Ferrara received the first tranche
of reparations from Venice. A coincidence?” and “The cards may well have
served as a ‘reward’ for Sanudo’s support since they are precisely the
kind of unique, expensive, visually engaging artefact that he, a
celebrated bibliophile, would subsequently have displayed in his
house.”. And, in Christophe Poncet’s turn: “Ficino
takes the precaution of introducing each and every work of Plato with a
commentary.” . The evidence for a c.1490
magical purpose is an inference from pictures, made by the person whose
book argues for it.
Third, and this is the central counterweight: a complete
secular account of the same artefact sits inside this book, and
the artefact cannot choose between them. On Adams’s own reading of the
deck’s political context, the occasion is the Salt War: “The 1482–84
Salt War with Venice had essentially bankrupted the state and destroyed
a large portion of her agricultural economy.”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part VII (“Tarot
designers”), Peter Adams except where marked. “The
Sola-Busca appears to have been preserved within titled circles until
its purchase by the Italian state in 2009 — a period of some five
hundred years. Prior to that, to the best of my knowledge, it only
appeared in the public domain on four occasions.”; “The first was when
some of the cards were described in Count Cicognara’s memoire on
intaglio printmaking in 1831; the second, when art historian and curator
Arthur M. Hind arranged an exhibition of black and white photographic
images of the cards in the British Museum in 1907, and then included
some images of the cards in his catalogue of early Italian engravings.”
and “The fourth exposure of the cards was via a limited edition
reproduction of the entire deck by Wolfgang Mayer in 1998, though I can
find no further information as to how or why he undertook this
project.”. “I personally find his attribution convincing based upon
stylistic comparisons with the artist’s other works”. “Now, assuming
that De Marchi is right about the engraver’s identity, and given the
generally accepted dates during which he was active as an artist
(1472–1501), then a date for the engraving work roughly concurrent with
the ostensible production date of 1491 is a reasonable conjecture.”;
“Since the colouration of the deck’s figures corresponds to the
theurgical energies to which the ritual processes depicted within it
relate, then we can assume that the theurgical knowledge encoded in the
cards was also current at the d’Este court in the same time frame.”. The
political account: “The 1482–84 Salt War with Venice had essentially
bankrupted the state and destroyed a large portion of her agricultural
economy.”; “the presence of the initials ‘MS’ and the encoding of the
date 1491 points towards the Venetian patrician, Marin Sanudo, as their
intended recipient”; “The date encoded on trump XIIII Bocho (fig.16),
1491, also marked the date at which Ferrara received the first tranche
of reparations from Venice. A coincidence?” and “The cards may well have
served as a ‘reward’ for Sanudo’s support since they are precisely the
kind of unique, expensive, visually engaging artefact that he, a
celebrated bibliophile, would subsequently have displayed in his
house.”. And, in Christophe Poncet’s turn: “Ficino
takes the precaution of introducing each and every work of Plato with a
commentary.” .
The arms on the cards are those of “the Venetian patrician Venier-Sanudo
family”; the initials and the date point “towards the Venetian
patrician, Marin Sanudo, as their intended recipient”, who was Venice’s
rapporteur on Ferrara’s reparations claim; and the date “also marked the
date at which Ferrara received the first tranche of reparations from
Venice”, about which Adams asks, “A coincidence?”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part VII (“Tarot
designers”), Peter Adams except where marked. “The
Sola-Busca appears to have been preserved within titled circles until
its purchase by the Italian state in 2009 — a period of some five
hundred years. Prior to that, to the best of my knowledge, it only
appeared in the public domain on four occasions.”; “The first was when
some of the cards were described in Count Cicognara’s memoire on
intaglio printmaking in 1831; the second, when art historian and curator
Arthur M. Hind arranged an exhibition of black and white photographic
images of the cards in the British Museum in 1907, and then included
some images of the cards in his catalogue of early Italian engravings.”
and “The fourth exposure of the cards was via a limited edition
reproduction of the entire deck by Wolfgang Mayer in 1998, though I can
find no further information as to how or why he undertook this
project.”. “I personally find his attribution convincing based upon
stylistic comparisons with the artist’s other works”. “Now, assuming
that De Marchi is right about the engraver’s identity, and given the
generally accepted dates during which he was active as an artist
(1472–1501), then a date for the engraving work roughly concurrent with
the ostensible production date of 1491 is a reasonable conjecture.”;
“Since the colouration of the deck’s figures corresponds to the
theurgical energies to which the ritual processes depicted within it
relate, then we can assume that the theurgical knowledge encoded in the
cards was also current at the d’Este court in the same time frame.”. The
political account: “The 1482–84 Salt War with Venice had essentially
bankrupted the state and destroyed a large portion of her agricultural
economy.”; “the presence of the initials ‘MS’ and the encoding of the
date 1491 points towards the Venetian patrician, Marin Sanudo, as their
intended recipient”; “The date encoded on trump XIIII Bocho (fig.16),
1491, also marked the date at which Ferrara received the first tranche
of reparations from Venice. A coincidence?” and “The cards may well have
served as a ‘reward’ for Sanudo’s support since they are precisely the
kind of unique, expensive, visually engaging artefact that he, a
celebrated bibliophile, would subsequently have displayed in his
house.”. And, in Christophe Poncet’s turn: “Ficino
takes the precaution of introducing each and every work of Plato with a
commentary.” .
His conclusion is a gift hypothesis: “The cards may well have served as
a ‘reward’ for Sanudo’s support since they are precisely the kind of
unique, expensive, visually engaging artefact that he, a celebrated
bibliophile, would subsequently have displayed in his house.”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part VII (“Tarot
designers”), Peter Adams except where marked. “The
Sola-Busca appears to have been preserved within titled circles until
its purchase by the Italian state in 2009 — a period of some five
hundred years. Prior to that, to the best of my knowledge, it only
appeared in the public domain on four occasions.”; “The first was when
some of the cards were described in Count Cicognara’s memoire on
intaglio printmaking in 1831; the second, when art historian and curator
Arthur M. Hind arranged an exhibition of black and white photographic
images of the cards in the British Museum in 1907, and then included
some images of the cards in his catalogue of early Italian engravings.”
and “The fourth exposure of the cards was via a limited edition
reproduction of the entire deck by Wolfgang Mayer in 1998, though I can
find no further information as to how or why he undertook this
project.”. “I personally find his attribution convincing based upon
stylistic comparisons with the artist’s other works”. “Now, assuming
that De Marchi is right about the engraver’s identity, and given the
generally accepted dates during which he was active as an artist
(1472–1501), then a date for the engraving work roughly concurrent with
the ostensible production date of 1491 is a reasonable conjecture.”;
“Since the colouration of the deck’s figures corresponds to the
theurgical energies to which the ritual processes depicted within it
relate, then we can assume that the theurgical knowledge encoded in the
cards was also current at the d’Este court in the same time frame.”. The
political account: “The 1482–84 Salt War with Venice had essentially
bankrupted the state and destroyed a large portion of her agricultural
economy.”; “the presence of the initials ‘MS’ and the encoding of the
date 1491 points towards the Venetian patrician, Marin Sanudo, as their
intended recipient”; “The date encoded on trump XIIII Bocho (fig.16),
1491, also marked the date at which Ferrara received the first tranche
of reparations from Venice. A coincidence?” and “The cards may well have
served as a ‘reward’ for Sanudo’s support since they are precisely the
kind of unique, expensive, visually engaging artefact that he, a
celebrated bibliophile, would subsequently have displayed in his
house.”. And, in Christophe Poncet’s turn: “Ficino
takes the precaution of introducing each and every work of Plato with a
commentary.” . In terms of what a third party can
check, the political account is the stronger: it has
dates, names and a treasury entry, and the magical one has the
design.
So the same deck has, in one book, a documented diplomatic occasion
with an encoded date, and a claimed magical purpose read from its
pictures — and the pictures are the evidence for both. A reading cannot
choose, and this one does not. What it can report is that the stronger
of the two claims, in terms of what a third party can check, is the
political one, because it has dates, names and a
treasury entry, and the magical one has the design.
Fourth: both speakers are arguing for their own prior work,
and neither is an academic — one of them says so. Poncet: “I
note in passing that none of us three is an academic”.Two Esoteric Tarots, Part XII (“The esoteric
call”). Christophe Poncet: “As soon as I started
investigating the Tarot de Marseille, I felt like I was mysteriously
helped every now and then, as if some providential hand was giving me
the clues needed to continue my progress.” ; “I note in passing that
none of us three is an academic”. Peter Adams, closing
the conversation: “I hope that our conversation has served to highlight
the importance that people have accorded to securing the performative in
relation to their spirituality: the ways and the means for connecting
directly to the numinous and experiencing the influx of the divine, and
doing so despite the risk of being exposed and punished, or even
executed, for their non-conformity of beliefs and practices.”; “The fact
is, the esoteric tarot is a living reality for the hundreds of thousands
of people who daily engage, through the mediation of its imagery, with
greatly expanded domains of awareness and understanding”.
Adams is the author of the book under discussion and Poncet of the
forthcoming one that closes the Marseille argument: self-interested
frame claims, made by interested parties, in a Scarlet Imprint edition.
That is a structure and not an accusation — a claim’s interest does not
make it false, and §4 is about why it does not need to be taken on trust
either. And the evidence chain has two interpreters at the end
of it, both of them the authors of the theses being tested: of
the threefold evidence at §4, two of the three analyses are by the two
people in the conversation.Two Esoteric Tarots, Part VIII (“The
Dummett-Yates controversy”). César Pedreros asks: “Why
is it that we cannot find books explicitly explaining the esoteric
significance of these images until French occultism emerged in the
eighteenth century? Were they destroyed? Were they simply never written?
Or was Michael Dummett right when he insisted that there was no such
thing as an esoteric tarot before the French occultists ‘discovered’ it
in the eighteenth century?”. Peter Adams,:
“Unfortunately, for many people it’s as though the clock became stuck
back in 1980 when Dummett published his study of the tarot as a game,
and has remained so ever since, so that merely referring to Dummett has
become a standard response on this issue — as though nothing has changed
in the intervening almost half century.”. “To be clear, the central
issue rests on Dummett’s claim that ‘no occult significance was attached
to the cards, nor any use made of them save for playing games, until the
intervention of Court de Gébelin in 1781.’”. “This topic formed the
subject of an exchange between Michael Dummett, a professor of logic and
expert on tarot games, and Frances Yates, a world-renowned expert on the
iconography and ideation of the Renaissance, in the context of Yates’s
review of Dummett’s The Game of Tarot.”; “Rather than rehearse
the intricacies of this exchange the issue rested, finally, on Dummett’s
appeal for, and openness towards, evidence overturning his statement.” .
“The evidence that neither Dummett nor Yates had access to in 1980 has
only become available over the last ten years or so, and it
fundamentally overturns Dummett’s supposition. Frances Yates was right
but lacked the specifics to establish her case.”. “The first piece of
evidence comes from the records of the Inquisition. A Venetian
courtesan, Isabella Bellochio, was stated to have ‘worshipped an image
of the devil by kneeling before it, with her hair loose, while
maintaining a lantern alight before it day and night … a light which
burned continuously in the kitchen in front of a devil and the tarocchi
…’” (ellipses in the original, the footnote there giving Martin, R.
(1989) Witchcraft and the Inquisition in Venice, 1550–1650,
163). “Surely this kind of dual-use of a portable, highly symbolic
source of imagery is only to be expected?”; “In this connection it is
interesting that the Sola-Busca’s trump XVII Ipeo is the only card to
show signs of wear on the paint surface. It appears to have been
thumb-marked by being repeatedly gripped or held at the mid-opposite
edges, which is not, of course, evidence of ritual use but it certainly
points towards prolonged and sustained contemplation of the image.”.
“Today, the evidence for the existence of occluded subtexts deliberately
hidden within the pre-Gébelin tarot is threefold. It comprises the
detailed analyses of the iconography of the Sola-Busca (Adams); the
early Tarot de Marseille (Poncet); and the Noblet Tarot de Marseille
(Appel).”; “So the answer to the question about the ‘missing evidence’
is that it was never missing. Some of it existed in official records;
the rest, by far the more impactful portion, was hidden, rather
artfully, in plain sight for these last five hundred years.”.
Christophe Poncet,: “I completely agree with Peter. The
cards themselves were the ‘missing evidence.’”; “Such writings do not
state ‘I have created a tarot deck that embodies my ideas and theurgical
practices,’ as the followers of Dummett seem to expect, because their
authors couldn’t express themselves openly.”; “He was a very intelligent
man. He was a professor of logic. And he knew a lot about philosophy,
but he seems not to have been familiar with the culture of the Italian
Renaissance. That probably explains his dry, austere and limited vision
of the tarot.”; “She wrote that Dummett should have spent more time
looking for the ideas embedded in the cards than to ‘chase obscure card
games’. To name the capacity of the cards to embed deep performative
knowledge, Yates chose the word ‘hieroglyph.’”. That is not a fault of
the book — but it is why the blog can read this book
and cannot rest on it.
7.
The negative finding: safeguard, metered pace, clinical referral
The series reports the presence or absence of a safeguard, a metered
pace and a clinical referral as search results, scoped
to the text of this edition. This book’s results are unambiguous, and
each is a different kind of absence.
“Safeguard” occurs once, and it is not a safeguard of the
reader. It is the convenor’s framing of a question about
transmission: “Throughout history, there has been a prevailing belief
that esoteric teachings should be safeguarded and
transmitted orally, exclusively to those prepared to receive them.”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part XI (“Orality,
writing & the art of memory”). César Pedreros asks:
“Throughout history, there has been a prevailing belief that esoteric
teachings should be safeguarded and transmitted orally, exclusively to
those prepared to receive them. This exclusivity was supposed to
maintain the integrity and sanctity of the knowledge.”.
Christophe Poncet: “The Tarot de Marseille, with its
multilayered content and combinatorial structure, is a fantastic
instrument to produce unique experiences in the reader, and in this way
excludes any form of literality.”. Peter Adams: “The
concept of the art, or theatre, of memory informs everything I’ve
written over the last twenty-five years. The reason is simple enough.
There are two distinct modes of religiosity: a ‘doctrinal mode’ and an
‘imagistic mode.’”; “Because of the transience of these experiences,
imagistic modes of religiosity require that their core ritual processes,
iconic imagery and visionary outcomes — rather than a body of fixed
doctrine — be encoded in a form that allows the restitution of the
ritual and verification of its efficacy and visionary outcomes. The
ideal form with which to capture these essential elements is that of the
Theatre of Memory.”. The “doctrinal”/“imagistic” distinction is there
credited to Whitehouse, H. (2002), “Modes of Religiosity”. The word belongs to the protection
of knowledge, held by an institution against the wrong
people. It is not a protection of a person from an experience, and the
two are not the same instrument.
There is no metered pace. “Pace” returns
six hits in the text and not one of them is a
rate: every occurrence is inside the word “space” — a space of
time, a ritual space, the twenty-two spaces of the trumps, a political
space, the efficacious space of the convenor’s dreams.Reported as a search result, and scoped to the text of
this edition. Case-insensitive counts over the book’s text.
Length: the Foreword is 1.8 per cent
of the text. Strong epistemic markers: “unequivocally”
occurs 1 time in the text, inside the Foreword;
“firmly” 3 times (in the Foreword, and twice
elsewhere); “shattered” 2 (in the Foreword, of the
scholarly consensus, and once more, of the medieval worldview);
“evident” 4 (one in the Foreword, three elsewhere).
Hedge markers, case-insensitive substring counts across the
whole text, the Foreword’s count in brackets: “probably” 20
(0), “seems” 10 (0), “likely” 8 (0), “may have” 7 (0), “apparently” 4
(0), “perhaps” 3 (0), “to my mind” 2 (0), “I guess” 1 (0), “I gather” 1
(0), “tentatively” 1 (0), “My suggestion” 1 (0), “conjecture” 1 (0),
“possible” 4 (0), “possibility” 1 (0) — 64 across the text, 0 in
the Foreword. Safeguard: “safeguard” returns
1 hit, inside “safeguarded”, in the convenor’s question
about transmitting knowledge. Pace: “pace” returns
6 hits and 0 as a word of its own;
every hit is inside “space” — “for a space of time”, “the ritual space”
twice, “twenty-two spaces”, “this turbulent political space” and “the
efficacious space of your own dreams”. Clinical and risk
vocabulary returning 0 hits: danger, warn, warning, doctor,
therap-, therapist, psychiatr-, psychiatric, psychiatry, psychotic,
clinical, hospital, crisis, suicid-, mental health, breakdown, seek
help, professional help, self-harm, mentor, dose, safety, ethic.
Near-misses: “risk” 1 (the historical
risk run by Renaissance practitioners); “precaution” 1
(Ficino’s commentary habit); “caution” 0 as a word of
its own and 1 as a substring of “precaution”; “madness”
2 (Ficino’s doctrine that the incarnate soul’s journey
“necessarily leads to a state of madness”, and an index entry);
“careful” 5 (all five about examining images or texts);
“psycho” 3, all inside “metempsychosis”; “supervis”
1 (Prisciani’s “design and supervision” of a fresco
cycle); “discipline” 2 (the Quadrivium, and “It is
highly disciplined”); “purif” 2 (of the soul);
“meditat” 8, of which 5 are the title of Tomberg’s
Meditations on the Tarot or references to it, 2 are “divination
and meditation”/“divination, meditative or ritual use”, and 1 is
“meditative ritual”. The word “third” occurs
1 time in the text (“thirdly” in Adams’s four decoding
steps) and does not appear in the third element of the deck’s four
public appearances. A search shows only what it indexes, so every count
here is scoped to the text of this edition.
Nothing in the book says how often, how much, or how fast. And here a
distinction the previous six readings did not have to make: this
is not a book with no practice. It states that a deck was an
operative ritual apparatus, describes the operation, dates its apparatus
to “as early as 700 BCE” and notes that it is “still practiced by occult
groups today”.Two Esoteric Tarots, Part III (“Decoding the
Sola-Busca”), Peter Adams, throughout: “At the deepest
level I found that the Sola-Busca’s iconographic programme was
structured around two key rituals. The first was an extremely archaic
ritual, one attested as early as 700 BCE and still practiced by occult
groups today. It is called ‘Drawing Down the Moon.’”. “In effect what
the ritual is doing is creating a magical child or homunculus that will
then be ‘sacrificed’ by immolation in the next stage of the ritual as
part of an invocation of the saturnian deity or current (whether
encompassed under the name of Ammon, Kronos or Saturn).”. “The designer
has sought to hide the ritual intent through the use of additional
references that draw our attention away from the performative ritual
narrative being enacted.”. “The second ritual encompasses the main
objective of the entire ritual sequence. It is a rite of theurgical
invocation whereby the operator seeks to become imbued with the
draconian energies of the deity.”. “He is shown using a globular ritual
implement that we find described in the principal text of theurgical
practice, the Chaldean Oracles, and known as Hekate’s Top.”;
“As far as I know, this is the only depiction of a theurgical operation
in the entire oeuvre of both esoteric and Renaissance art.”. “My
suggestion is that only one reading — that identifying a deeply
heretical theurgical ritual — reflects the intent of the designer since
this alone is consistent with the deck’s other ritually-infused
imagery.”. “Considered in isolation, the cards are inherently
polysemous. We therefore need to assemble a group of cards in order to
understand how they function together and this allows us to begin to
recover the deck’s deeper levels of meaning.”. On method, from the same
part and cited in the body as the four named steps: the deck’s
“celestial and sidereal symbolism — references to the solstices,
planets, fixed stars and constellations”; the “surplus imagery left over
after accounting for the other elements”, which yielded “a distinctive
postural and gestural grammar — what I have called a ‘ritual grammar’”;
and the gesture “known as aposkopein; a characteristic gesture
made in the presence of an epiphany of a deity. We find this gesture
attested from at least the second millennium BCE in the context of
Minoan and Mycenaean iconography.”. A reader who took any of it as a
manual would hold a manual’s shape and none of a manual’s fences. The
nearest thing to a discipline in the book is a discipline of
work — “you would need to be an astrologer to make all
of the calculations”, “highly disciplined — which is, of course, a
highly Saturnian quality.”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part IX (“Cyphers and
time”). Christophe Poncet: “If we think of the game as
a combinatorial system, you need every part to make it work. So, it’s a
complete system and each part has its function.”. “My research shows
that the Tarot de Marseille was designed between 1470 and 1475. The
Sola-Busca was probably created about ten years later in reaction to
Ficino’s deck, proposing in similar ways an opposite ideology.”; and, on
Ficino’s doctrine of the incarnate soul: “For him, the journey of the
soul during physical life necessarily leads to a state of madness. The
soul becomes crazed when it is incarnated because, being immortal, her
natural state is not to be imprisoned in a body, it is to be united with
God.”. Peter Adams: “What I perceive with respect to
the Sola-Busca is that each of the trumps, and certain of the suit
cards, form an elaborate cypher composed of some combination of
historical or literary references, astro-alchemical allusions and ritual
postures, gestures and magical implements. That being said, the recovery
of the ‘sense’ — the cards’ deeper narratives — requires that these
figures be grouped together in specific combinations.”. On time: “These
operations depend upon drawing in very specific forces — the energies of
Mars, Saturn and chthonic Mercury under the influence of the most
malefic of fixed stars, Algol — at the time of their maximum strength.
There’s a high degree of precision in the calculations required to
achieve this. You would need to be an astrologer to make all of the
calculations … All of the other operations would require equally precise
timing — the collection of the menstruum, the preparation of the ritual
space, garments, implements and the person of the Mage. With the
Sola-Busca, therefore, we encounter time in its most instrumental
sense”. “The whole operation functions like a very complicated,
intricate timepiece … In other words, we find ourselves at a very
instrumental end of the spiritual spectrum, one more usually associated
with goetia than with classical theurgy. This is a technocratic,
astrologically-driven vision of the universe as a collection of
manipulable forces. Ritually, the deck does not pose a question, it
instructs us on how to draw this power down in its rawest form and
manifest it into the external world. It is highly disciplined — which
is, of course, a highly Saturnian quality.”.
There is no clinical referral at all, and the vocabulary of
risk is almost wholly absent. A case-insensitive search returns
0 hits for “danger”, “warn” and “warning”, “doctor”,
“therapy”, “therapist”, “psychiatric”, “psychiatry”, “psychotic”,
“clinical”, “hospital”, “crisis”, “suicid”, “mental health”,
“breakdown”, “seek help”, “professional help”, “self-harm”, “mentor” and
“dose”.Reported as a search result, and scoped to the text of
this edition. Case-insensitive counts over the book’s text.
Length: the Foreword is 1.8 per cent
of the text. Strong epistemic markers: “unequivocally”
occurs 1 time in the text, inside the Foreword;
“firmly” 3 times (in the Foreword, and twice
elsewhere); “shattered” 2 (in the Foreword, of the
scholarly consensus, and once more, of the medieval worldview);
“evident” 4 (one in the Foreword, three elsewhere).
Hedge markers, case-insensitive substring counts across the
whole text, the Foreword’s count in brackets: “probably” 20
(0), “seems” 10 (0), “likely” 8 (0), “may have” 7 (0), “apparently” 4
(0), “perhaps” 3 (0), “to my mind” 2 (0), “I guess” 1 (0), “I gather” 1
(0), “tentatively” 1 (0), “My suggestion” 1 (0), “conjecture” 1 (0),
“possible” 4 (0), “possibility” 1 (0) — 64 across the text, 0 in
the Foreword. Safeguard: “safeguard” returns
1 hit, inside “safeguarded”, in the convenor’s question
about transmitting knowledge. Pace: “pace” returns
6 hits and 0 as a word of its own;
every hit is inside “space” — “for a space of time”, “the ritual space”
twice, “twenty-two spaces”, “this turbulent political space” and “the
efficacious space of your own dreams”. Clinical and risk
vocabulary returning 0 hits: danger, warn, warning, doctor,
therap-, therapist, psychiatr-, psychiatric, psychiatry, psychotic,
clinical, hospital, crisis, suicid-, mental health, breakdown, seek
help, professional help, self-harm, mentor, dose, safety, ethic.
Near-misses: “risk” 1 (the historical
risk run by Renaissance practitioners); “precaution” 1
(Ficino’s commentary habit); “caution” 0 as a word of
its own and 1 as a substring of “precaution”; “madness”
2 (Ficino’s doctrine that the incarnate soul’s journey
“necessarily leads to a state of madness”, and an index entry);
“careful” 5 (all five about examining images or texts);
“psycho” 3, all inside “metempsychosis”; “supervis”
1 (Prisciani’s “design and supervision” of a fresco
cycle); “discipline” 2 (the Quadrivium, and “It is
highly disciplined”); “purif” 2 (of the soul);
“meditat” 8, of which 5 are the title of Tomberg’s
Meditations on the Tarot or references to it, 2 are “divination
and meditation”/“divination, meditative or ritual use”, and 1 is
“meditative ritual”. The word “third” occurs
1 time in the text (“thirdly” in Adams’s four decoding
steps) and does not appear in the third element of the deck’s four
public appearances. A search shows only what it indexes, so every count
here is scoped to the text of this edition. Four terms do occur and none is a
referral: “risk” once, a historical
risk the source names without a date; “precaution”
once, and it is Ficino’s; “careful”
five times, every one about reading images; and
“madness” twice, once as Neoplatonic doctrine.Reported as a search result, and scoped to the text of
this edition. Case-insensitive counts over the book’s text.
Length: the Foreword is 1.8 per cent
of the text. Strong epistemic markers: “unequivocally”
occurs 1 time in the text, inside the Foreword;
“firmly” 3 times (in the Foreword, and twice
elsewhere); “shattered” 2 (in the Foreword, of the
scholarly consensus, and once more, of the medieval worldview);
“evident” 4 (one in the Foreword, three elsewhere).
Hedge markers, case-insensitive substring counts across the
whole text, the Foreword’s count in brackets: “probably” 20
(0), “seems” 10 (0), “likely” 8 (0), “may have” 7 (0), “apparently” 4
(0), “perhaps” 3 (0), “to my mind” 2 (0), “I guess” 1 (0), “I gather” 1
(0), “tentatively” 1 (0), “My suggestion” 1 (0), “conjecture” 1 (0),
“possible” 4 (0), “possibility” 1 (0) — 64 across the text, 0 in
the Foreword. Safeguard: “safeguard” returns
1 hit, inside “safeguarded”, in the convenor’s question
about transmitting knowledge. Pace: “pace” returns
6 hits and 0 as a word of its own;
every hit is inside “space” — “for a space of time”, “the ritual space”
twice, “twenty-two spaces”, “this turbulent political space” and “the
efficacious space of your own dreams”. Clinical and risk
vocabulary returning 0 hits: danger, warn, warning, doctor,
therap-, therapist, psychiatr-, psychiatric, psychiatry, psychotic,
clinical, hospital, crisis, suicid-, mental health, breakdown, seek
help, professional help, self-harm, mentor, dose, safety, ethic.
Near-misses: “risk” 1 (the historical
risk run by Renaissance practitioners); “precaution” 1
(Ficino’s commentary habit); “caution” 0 as a word of
its own and 1 as a substring of “precaution”; “madness”
2 (Ficino’s doctrine that the incarnate soul’s journey
“necessarily leads to a state of madness”, and an index entry);
“careful” 5 (all five about examining images or texts);
“psycho” 3, all inside “metempsychosis”; “supervis”
1 (Prisciani’s “design and supervision” of a fresco
cycle); “discipline” 2 (the Quadrivium, and “It is
highly disciplined”); “purif” 2 (of the soul);
“meditat” 8, of which 5 are the title of Tomberg’s
Meditations on the Tarot or references to it, 2 are “divination
and meditation”/“divination, meditative or ritual use”, and 1 is
“meditative ritual”. The word “third” occurs
1 time in the text (“thirdly” in Adams’s four decoding
steps) and does not appear in the third element of the deck’s four
public appearances. A search shows only what it indexes, so every count
here is scoped to the text of this edition. Not one is addressed to a person’s
safety.
Read as a structure rather than a gap, that is a different
result from the last two readings. Undreaming Wetiko
named psychiatry as an adversary; Star.Ships named it not at
all, and had no practice to fence. This book is the third case: it
issues no instruction, and it does describe an operative ritual — so the
absence here is not merely the absence of a subject that never arose. It
is a shape without its fences: a book that has told the
reader that a deck was built to perform a rite, and that has nothing to
say about what happens to anyone who tries. The honest reading of that
is limited — a search shows only what it indexes, and a conversation
between two researchers about fifteenth-century artefacts is not the
genre in which a route to a clinician would be expected.
8. The correction the blog
owes
One correction, stated once, and then its second clause.
The blog’s frame inventory has been a list of environments,
and it now needs an object. A tarot deck is not a cosmology: it is a
fixed correspondence system, plus a set of positions, plus a reader who
supplies the reading, and it is carried, dealt and read rather than
lived in. It supplies the series with a frame type the case studies
could not reach — a frame made portable and instrumental — and it splits
the blog’s single test in two, because the table is public, fixed and
checkable while the utterance is issued in the first person by someone
who benefits from it. The blog had one question for a frame. An object
asks two, and the history has been argued on the half that can survive
being checked.
The clause that follows is about the
environment’s fourth lever — “a pre-certified frame”. That lever was
written about a culture supplying the warrant for a
teacher, and the blog has never had to carry it into a
case where the warrant is claimed by named living researchers for an
artwork. Here it is, and the carrier is different in a
way that matters: the authority invoked is the object of study. So the
second correction is narrower than the first and sharper:
The warrant lever has a second carrier — a researcher
claiming a warrant for an artwork, with the certifying authority being
the very material under investigation — and the blog should carry its
shape without importing its charge. There is no predator in this book.
What the lever is good for here is a question, not an accusation: does
the authority cited certify the claim being made with it? In this book
the answer is checkable, and it is no — Ficino’s planets do not
influence the sublunar world, on the book’s own account of him, and the
deck that needs them to is not his.
Neither correction touches anything the blog has argued about frames,
seats or checks. Both change what the blog may say it read: a series
about cosmologies has just taken an object as a source, and a series
about warrants has just found one issued for a picture.
9. What a reading is for
A reading holds one source whole and asks what a blog that has quoted
sources all along now has to change. This one returns a convergence, a
correction and a gap.
The convergence is that the blog’s test arrived as a real
dispute, and survived it. The series’ requirement — a check
that does not benefit from the answer — has been found missing in
six successive readings, in every cosmology it has examined. Here the
blog’s question about frames is being fought over by named people, in
dated, public, third-party-readable documents, over an object that sits
in a national gallery, with one of the parties on record as asking for
the evidence that would refute him. That is a frame being checked by
someone who does not benefit — not by an insider’s rite, not by a
lineage, not by a credential of any kind.
The correction is an inventory correction with a hypothesis
inside it. The series has four frames, all cosmologies, and its
rule about frames was written at cosmological scale: keep the endpoint
unnamed, keep the route plural, keep a check that does not stand to
gain. A deck is the first frame the blog has met that names its
endpoint, has a single fixed route, and sits in a hand — and it
is not a failing frame, because it is not claiming to be an environment.
It is an instrument, and an instrument’s check is whether the thing
works: a different question from whether a cosmology is true, and one
the blog has never asked in this register. That does not weaken the
rule. It locates it: the rule about frames is a rule about
environments.
And the gap is the one the blog keeps finding. Two
researchers, each the author of the thesis he is defending, are the only
interpreters at the end of the evidence they have assembled; the
strongest sentence in the book is the convenor’s; the dating is an
inference from imagery, marked as such by the person making it. This
book supplies a public record and not a second reader
of the object — and the record, unusually, is enough for the one thing
the blog needed, which is that the argument be auditable. The blog can
cite the dispute. It cannot cite either party to it.
Which leaves the reading’s own bottom line, handed over almost
unrepaired by the researcher who has spent the most years with a deck
bought for him on a nineteenth birthday: the Tarot de Marseille “with
its multilayered content and combinatorial structure, is a fantastic
instrument to produce unique experiences in the reader, and in this way
excludes any form of literality.”Two Esoteric Tarots, Part XI (“Orality,
writing & the art of memory”). César Pedreros asks:
“Throughout history, there has been a prevailing belief that esoteric
teachings should be safeguarded and transmitted orally, exclusively to
those prepared to receive them. This exclusivity was supposed to
maintain the integrity and sanctity of the knowledge.”.
Christophe Poncet: “The Tarot de Marseille, with its
multilayered content and combinatorial structure, is a fantastic
instrument to produce unique experiences in the reader, and in this way
excludes any form of literality.”. Peter Adams: “The
concept of the art, or theatre, of memory informs everything I’ve
written over the last twenty-five years. The reason is simple enough.
There are two distinct modes of religiosity: a ‘doctrinal mode’ and an
‘imagistic mode.’”; “Because of the transience of these experiences,
imagistic modes of religiosity require that their core ritual processes,
iconic imagery and visionary outcomes — rather than a body of fixed
doctrine — be encoded in a form that allows the restitution of the
ritual and verification of its efficacy and visionary outcomes. The
ideal form with which to capture these essential elements is that of the
Theatre of Memory.”. The “doctrinal”/“imagistic” distinction is there
credited to Whitehouse, H. (2002), “Modes of Religiosity”. The blog has been
saying a version of that about frames at every scale — that the frame
supplies the reading, and that whoever supplies the reading holds the
lever. It now has it from inside the trade, in a sentence that does not
know it is a finding: an instrument produces experiences. It
does not certify them.
Notes
Marking: a reading. Documented — every
passage in quotation marks, taken from a complete digital text of
Two Esoteric Tarots by Peter Mark Adams and Christophe Poncet,
convened and with a foreword by César Pedreros (Scarlet Imprint, 2023,
eISBN 978-1-912316-92-2), checked character for character against it and
cited in the notes by part and by speaker, because the
book is a recorded conversation and its claims belong to the person who
made them. Address: the text’s typographic quotes are
rendered here as straight ASCII, and its dashes are given as em dashes
except inside numeric ranges (which keep its en dashes); the small-caps
opening of the Foreword is quoted in lower case with the rendering
noted; the stray spaces its italics markup leaves before punctuation are
closed. Absences reported as search results, scoped to the text
of this edition: no safeguard of a reader (the single
occurrence of “safeguarded” concerns transmitting knowledge); no metered
pace (all six hits for “pace” are inside “space”); and 0 hits for the
clinical and risk vocabulary listed in note Reported as a search result, and scoped to the text of
this edition. Case-insensitive counts over the book’s text.
Length: the Foreword is 1.8 per cent
of the text. Strong epistemic markers: “unequivocally”
occurs 1 time in the text, inside the Foreword;
“firmly” 3 times (in the Foreword, and twice
elsewhere); “shattered” 2 (in the Foreword, of the
scholarly consensus, and once more, of the medieval worldview);
“evident” 4 (one in the Foreword, three elsewhere).
Hedge markers, case-insensitive substring counts across the
whole text, the Foreword’s count in brackets: “probably” 20
(0), “seems” 10 (0), “likely” 8 (0), “may have” 7 (0), “apparently” 4
(0), “perhaps” 3 (0), “to my mind” 2 (0), “I guess” 1 (0), “I gather” 1
(0), “tentatively” 1 (0), “My suggestion” 1 (0), “conjecture” 1 (0),
“possible” 4 (0), “possibility” 1 (0) — 64 across the text, 0 in
the Foreword. Safeguard: “safeguard” returns
1 hit, inside “safeguarded”, in the convenor’s question
about transmitting knowledge. Pace: “pace” returns
6 hits and 0 as a word of its own;
every hit is inside “space” — “for a space of time”, “the ritual space”
twice, “twenty-two spaces”, “this turbulent political space” and “the
efficacious space of your own dreams”. Clinical and risk
vocabulary returning 0 hits: danger, warn, warning, doctor,
therap-, therapist, psychiatr-, psychiatric, psychiatry, psychotic,
clinical, hospital, crisis, suicid-, mental health, breakdown, seek
help, professional help, self-harm, mentor, dose, safety, ethic.
Near-misses: “risk” 1 (the historical
risk run by Renaissance practitioners); “precaution” 1
(Ficino’s commentary habit); “caution” 0 as a word of
its own and 1 as a substring of “precaution”; “madness”
2 (Ficino’s doctrine that the incarnate soul’s journey
“necessarily leads to a state of madness”, and an index entry);
“careful” 5 (all five about examining images or texts);
“psycho” 3, all inside “metempsychosis”; “supervis”
1 (Prisciani’s “design and supervision” of a fresco
cycle); “discipline” 2 (the Quadrivium, and “It is
highly disciplined”); “purif” 2 (of the soul);
“meditat” 8, of which 5 are the title of Tomberg’s
Meditations on the Tarot or references to it, 2 are “divination
and meditation”/“divination, meditative or ritual use”, and 1 is
“meditative ritual”. The word “third” occurs
1 time in the text (“thirdly” in Adams’s four decoding
steps) and does not appear in the third element of the deck’s four
public appearances. A search shows only what it indexes, so every count
here is scoped to the text of this edition.,
with “risk” once, as a historical danger the text leaves undated.
Inferred, as this post’s contribution: that a tarot
deck is a frame made portable and instrumental — a
correspondence system plus positions plus a reader — and therefore a
frame type the blog’s cosmological inventory does not
contain; that it splits the blog’s single frame-test into a checkable
table and an uncheckable utterance; and that the closing of the seat in
a reading is a claim about who is speaking rather than a claim about the
deck. Not adjudicated: the question whether the tarot
was esoteric before the mid-eighteenth century; the book is read as
showing that the dispute over it is checkable — dated,
named, public and third-party-readable — and this post takes no side in
it, and has not read Dummett, Depaulis or Yates.
The gap, stated: the two interpreters at the end of the
book’s evidence are the two authors of the theses it defends, the
strongest sentence in it is the convenor’s, the dating of the Sola-Busca
is an inference from imagery that the book itself marks as a conjecture,
and the criterion of adequacy on offer is explanatory completeness
rather than falsifiability. No cosmology is endorsed —
nothing here claims the cards carry magical power and nothing claims
they do not — and no living person is diagnosed.